Which album is better?

[jesusarenque]

[calmasahinducow]

Voted Moondance and it's not even close

[posnera]

Very tough call. Astral Weeks is a better album as an entirety, while the best songs on Moondance are probably better. Both are essential listening.

I voted Astral Weeks, because I am an album kind of guy.

[jesusarenque]

This poll was inspired by the "desert island discs" thread. I know one of these two would be one of my three, but I couldn't decide which one.

[shadow.]

Astral Weeks, not close.

Read this article everyone:

http://www.harbour.sfu.ca/~hayward/v...ws/astral.html

[GBP04]

I am pretty sure that at least half of these votes will be by people who don't know who these albums are by.

[mrcoughman]

Astral weeks is bar none the better overall album. Moondance just has more radio friendly singles

[nath]

I voted Astral Weeks. I think they're both great but Astral Weeks is... transcendent.

And yeah read the Lester Bangs column.

[bort411]

[ QUOTE ]
Astral Weeks, not close.

Read this article everyone:

http://www.harbour.sfu.ca/~hayward/v...ws/astral.html

[/ QUOTE ]

Reading that just reminds me how awesome White Light/White Heat is. I voted for Moondance.

[Dan BRIGHT]

I didnt vote because its nopt like one vote counts anyways