Guns n' Roses Elite Eight poll

[ScottieK]

All right, Guns n’ Roses fans…I’ve decided to match the eight clear favorites against each other, Get In the Ring style (nice one, Yeti.) What better way to get in #1000? Please vote for your favorites. Yowza!

[ScottieK]

Went Estranged - Appetite straight line. I do realize the power of November Rain though. And so far I can tell you're all true fans since nobody has voted "yes" on #5.





Listened to Appetite at lunch today...

Now you're clean
And so discreet
I won't say a word
But most of all this song is true
Case you haven't heard
So c'mon and stop your cryin'
'Cause we both know money burns
Honey don't stop tryin;
An you'll get what you deserve

ScottieK

[BradleyT]

None of those songs are even good except WTTJ.

[El Diablo]

Bradley: STFU

Scottie: This poll is a testament to the greatness of Appetite. I chose the same line as you, of course.

[EvilSmurf]

The 'Appetite' songs were a sweep for me, except "November Rain" and Velvet Revolver is more GNR than Axl's current band, but even VR ain't nothing like GNR.

[BradleyT]

Masked One,

I have Appetite on my Real Player Playlist as the first album to play. I listen to it every night. I saw GnR open for Alice Cooper 18 years ago. I'm a fully qualified GnR fan.

The songs listed above are mediocre at best.


The same thing would happen if a Metallica poll was posted - gay songs like "Enter Sandman" or "Nothing Else Matters" would be the most popular.

[SackUp]

Welcome to the Jungle is my fave, followed by Paradise City.

[MEbenhoe]

November Rain
Paradise City
Knockin on Heaven's Door
Civil War

[El Diablo]

MEbenhoe: HAHAHHAHA

Bradley: You listen to Appetite every night? OK, dude, that is weird. I saw them open for the Cult. I think that was only 17 years ago, though. I will have to look into that. Anyway, it sounds like you have listened to a lot of GnR, but still have problems identifying good songs. Or maybe you're just one of these guys who is anti-popular stuff.

[uncleshady]

Sucks that Estranged and November Rain are in the same bracket. Sigh.