Simple Question For Not Ready And Others

[David Sklansky]

You have stated that God does not want anyone to ever flat out say or believe that someone else will, or will not, be saved.

You have also stated that non believers cannot be saved unless they change, per your reading of the bible.

So here is my question.

If Joe Schmo tells you on his deathbed that he doesn't believe and I ask you "will he be saved" and you answer (as you say you must) "I don't know", do you answer that way

A) Because there is a possibility that Joe will change his mind the last possible second

B) Because there is a possibility that Joe lied to you

C) Because you are lying when you say you don't know, to avoid God's wrath

D) Because God is not bound by syllogisms, in this case

Non believers are not saved

Joe is a non believer

Joe will not be saved.