Parlaying a threesome

[PoBoy321]

So this girl I've been hooking up with lately, we've been on and off for like three years or something, but I had a girlfriend for two of those years, now we've broken up, I'm with this girl again, but she kinda has a boyfriend, whatever.

Here's my story. I'm sitting with this girl at a bar a few weeks ago, when this quasi-friend of hers sits down next to us. This girl is completely batshit crazy but prett cute, so who cares. My girl leans over to me and says "This girl has wanted to hook up with me for the last two years," which is cool. Then she says "She's given me an open invitation that if I'm ever with a guy and we want a third, she'd be happy to do it." [censored] awesome. Then she leans over to me and says "The offer is still open."

At the time, I wasn't completely sure how to react, but the girl I'm with very quickly said that it's basically not gonna happen, simply because she's really not interested in being with another girl.

How can I convince her that either a) being with another girl wouldn't be such a bad thing or b) in a threesome, it's really not like she's with the other girl so much as it's like she's with me while this other girl is with me?

Discuss.

[neuroman]

I don't understand this [censored], MSPaint diagram please.

[PoBoy321]

[KidLifeCrisis]

[ QUOTE ]
I don't understand this [censored], MSPaint diagram please.

[/ QUOTE ]

[jbrent33]

+

[KidLifeCrisis]

This thread has enormous potential...

[NT!]

wait i am confused it sounds like there are three women in this story who is offering what

[fish2plus2]

PoBoy,

I would just butter her up and approach it as "please, please, please, what do you want in return? ill buy you that handbag, take you to this island" etc

[PoBoy321]

[ QUOTE ]
wait i am confused it sounds like there are three women in this story who is offering what

[/ QUOTE ]

There are two women, although I admit I'm kinda being a bitch about it.

There's this one girl, we'll call her Girl A, who I've been [censored]. There is this other girl, Girl B, who was good friends with Girl A's roommate freshman year, who has wanted to hook up with Girl A since then. Girl B told Girl A that she wanted to have a threesome between Girl B, Girl A and myself.

EDIT: Girl A is not my girlfriend. Girl B lives across the street from me and I see her either on the street, or at various bars all the time, and just [censored] Girl B is not entirely out of the question.

[tboss888]

I would go with the angle that she doesnt have to interact with other girl plus buy her stuff.