Top 10 Best Players in the NBA

[I am fish]

The current Top 10 Best Players in the NBA...

1. Kevin Garnett
2. LeBron James
3. Dwyane Wade
4. Elton Brand
5. Kobe Bryant
6. Shaquille O'Neal
7. Tim Duncan
8. Allen Iverson
9. Steve Nash
10. Dirk Nowitzki

[Hornacek]

KG #1 is insane.

Edit: Learn to spell Shaq's name too.

[Fallen Hero]

This was done a few weeks ago (although I can't find it using the search)

[gettym]

Seen this thread about 100x....

1. Lebron
2. Kobe
3. Dirk
4. Nash
5. Tim
6. KG
7. Brand
8. Wade
9. Shaq
10. AI

By the way... if T-Mac is healthy he is top 5, probably in place of Nash

[Hornacek]

These are so arbitrary and will certainly cause flaming, so flame away. Here is my metric: If I'm building a team for this ONE upcoming season with the idea of winning the championship, I choose this person. I don't care about ticket sales and the future. Moreoever, assume the normal health over the course of this player's future. This takes tMac off the list, and brings into question Shaq's availability for the entire season.

1. Tim Duncan
2. Kobe Bryant
3. LeBron James
4. Dwyane Wade
5. Elton Brand
6. Dirk Nowitzki (he moves way up if he can close out Spurs and his D is really for real)
7. Steve Nash
8. Jason Kidd
9. Allen Iverson
10. KG (maybe, could also see Billups, Pierce, or Arenas here as well)

[Fallen Hero]

in no particular order:

Duncan
Wade
Lebron
Carter
Shaq
Dirk
Nash
AI
KG
Kobe

[THAY3R]

These threads always just turn into a "Nash is overrated" "NO OMGLOLZBBQ he is awesome" thread.

[Victor]

tho the threads not original your no1 pic is. nice.

to the rest, i think the difference between lebron and kobe was made apparent in these playoffs. rather than quit and pout down 9 late in the game after being bottled up the whole game lebron decided to take over. kobe should drop a ton after seeing that game 7.

lol at everyone saying they would take kobe to win any one game.

lol at all the jordan comparisons before. someone should bump that thread actually.

[Victor]

hornacek,

did you watch the suns/lakers series? did you watch game 7? did you watch the second half? kobe revealed himself a headcase of nearly artest proportions. how can rate him so high when he sabotaged his team in the most important minutes of the season?

[Hornacek]

Victor, Kobe is on TNT halftime show tonight. Chaz is sure to berate him for Game 7. I reserve the right to change my rankings after I watch what he has to say tonight.

fwiw I hate his guts, but I still have him ranked highly as a player. If he did indeed tank Game 7, then he will drop a lot. Fact of the matter, he's won a lot (3 titles), which is more than any other "superstar" currently playing and tied with Dunc and Shack.

I really couldn't justify putting Wade or LBJ higher than Kobe. At least not now.