***** STAR WARS : A New Hope - Game thread *****

[dmk]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
rand has informed me that clown, tfg, soah, hornacek, and xorbie are evil.

[/ QUOTE ]

Your rand is amazingly accurate.

[/ QUOTE ]

TFG

[Nicholasp27]

what do u guys think about luke coming out tomorrow? obi can protect him...

the downside is if a baddie decides to role claim as luke...but he'll then have to give accurate peeks each day or else we'll know he's faking...and eventually we'll find real luke and so fake luke will be lynched, which is 20% of the wolves, so i don't think they'll fake it

[RichC.]

well, its still early, so I will wait till tonight to make a decision.

[fnord_too]

[ QUOTE ]
So...I have deduced that either Fnord is not reading the thread or is ignoring me. Neither option is good....

I think I will mull this over while reloading my ammo. I have a 1-bullet gun.

[/ QUOTE ]

I wait until the third day to revenge vote, so it doesn't look so obvious and I can delude myself that it is a good cause.

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
what do u guys think about luke coming out tomorrow? obi can protect him...

the downside is if a baddie decides to role claim as luke...but he'll then have to give accurate peeks each day or else we'll know he's faking...and eventually we'll find real luke and so fake luke will be lynched, which is 20% of the wolves, so i don't think they'll fake it

[/ QUOTE ]

I think this depends on a lot of factors - mostly who gets killed day 1 and who Luke peeks night 1, too many possibilities for this kind of sweeping decision yet

[traz]

yea tfg, are you bad?

[Nicholasp27]

actually, this is a bad idea

they can roleblock luke if he comes out

[Nicholasp27]

once their roleblocker is dead, luke can come out if obi is still alive...if luke is dead, then chewy can come out after their roleblocker is dead

but yeah, as long as they have a roleblocker, play your normal seer game

[dmk]

[ QUOTE ]
actually, this is a bad idea

they can roleblock luke if he comes out

[/ QUOTE ]

and evil seer can very easily fake

[Nicholasp27]

i don't mind faking...they have to give TRUE roles if they fake or else we'll know they are faking and they will be lynched...not worth losing 1/5 wolves over...

but roleblocking is a problem