The Soprano's: All in the Family Game Thread

[Neil S]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Zurvan: You can disagree with that logic all you want. but it's utterly disingenuous to say that I didn't have any logic.

[/ QUOTE ]

So, that's the only reason you think IY is a wolf?

Regardless, I'm out, and my vote is staying.

[/ QUOTE ]Yeah, if deducing the action of an evil player protecting a teammate counts as an "only" reason, then that's the only reason I think IY is a wolf.

And we lose if I can't get someone else to switch here, if you're really out. Dang it, that's one annoying thing about long games, when peopel can't be here at the end.

[FCBLComish]

[ QUOTE ]
Dang it, that's one annoying thing about long games, when peopel can't be here at the end.

[/ QUOTE ]

Not everyone has NO life like me.

[Neil S]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
FCBL: the trick here is that this is about more than just IY here. I'm a lead wagon. I'm trying to shoot down Zurvan's bogus attack on me, combined with Eskimo and Herbie's nonsense handwaving of a role for me.

I'm trying to show that Zurvan's just making up these attacks on me as he's going along, in order to make sure we DO lynch Siegmund's pick here.

[/ QUOTE ]


Neil, straight up, do you think Zurvan is a wolf?

[/ QUOTE ]50/50. I try not to fall into the trap of calling wolfy people who disagree with you, but looking at how his attacks on me make as little sense as his clearing of IY, it really makes me wonder.

Add in the fact that he seems to beon Eskimo's team on IY, and it seems to fall into place.

So I'm torn. I don't think he's the best lynch today by far, but if we weren't in such dire straits I'd be screaming to get him or IY here.

[FCBLComish]

[ QUOTE ]
50/50. I try not to fall into the trap of calling wolfy people who disagree with you, but looking at how his attacks on me make as little sense as his clearing of IY, it really makes me wonder.

Add in the fact that he seems to beon Eskimo's team on IY, and it seems to fall into place.

So I'm torn. I don't think he's the best lynch today by far, but if we weren't in such dire straits I'd be screaming to get him or IY here.

[/ QUOTE ]

Good, so now that you agree that we are in dire straits, and that he is not the best lynch here and neither is IY, FIND someone else. All you have to do is convince one person, Siegmund. Reread, use logic, whatever.

[Neil S]

FCBL, I've agreed all day long we're possibly doomed here. I understand the gravity, and I understand the job.

And effectively I AM arguing toward Siegmund here. By pointing out the wolves, and the tactics they're using, trying to save Eskimo, I'm hoping to show him that the attacks on me are false, and Eskimo needs to remain his vote.

[Neil S]

I'd feel a whole lot more comfortable here if we had a cushion. Right now it's a coinflip right?

[Neil S]

ASPOKER: You've been on me all game long. If the reverse were true, you'd be mocking me constantly, saying 'lolo standard' and whatever.

For once, just do the right flipping thing and save us from losing here.

[FCBLComish]

[ QUOTE ]
I'd feel a whole lot more comfortable here if we had a cushion. Right now it's a coinflip right?

[/ QUOTE ]


Coinflip + Junior + 2 vote buyers. Something like that.

[wdcbooks]

This is completely ridiculous.

There is only one way we lynch a wolf tonight. That is by hoping that our one confirmed villager makes a good decision and chooses the right guy. Herbie is absolutely a wolf, which means I am feeling just sick about my play. He is trying desperately to push Siegmund away from Eskimo.

I don't know who the wolves are, all I know is that having votes spread out of five people, or trying to find someone everyone can agree to is a strategy that has no chance of success whatsoever, and the people claiming it does are all wolves.

I am voting Eskimo because that is what Siegmund has chosen. If he chose Zurvan, or Mark I would be there as well.

[FCBLComish]

Books, that makes sense.

ESKIMO

Siegmund, let us know if you will be moving.