#11
|
|||
|
|||
Re: AP thread 87.1 - AP and UB ownership puzzle
DanDruff,
While I don't disagree with how you state AP should repay us some money, I am wondering how you would advise they address hypothetical situations. Like say this hand, which occurred during the midst of myself and baronzeus and several others discussing graycat and his "god like abilities" and beginning to suspect something was awry: STAGE #746347738: HOLDEM NORMAL $200/$400 - 2007-08-27 21:35:12 (ET) Table: LOC NESS AVE (Real Money) Seat #5 is the dealer Seat 5 - BERGENISGAY ($18582 in chips) Seat 6 - TRUTHY ($10645 in chips) Seat 7 - EZ2PLY ($7840 in chips) Seat 8 - GEMMER ($9153 in chips) Seat 9 - MAVERI9 ($3162.50 in chips) Seat 1 - SCHDNFRD ($24712.50 in chips) Seat 2 - PUNKIN_U ($11576.32 in chips) Seat 3 - LEAVINGEGYPT ($11085 in chips) Seat 4 - GRAYCAT ($19612 in chips) TRUTHY - Posts small blind $100 EZ2PLY - Posts big blind $200 *** POCKET CARDS *** Dealt to PUNKIN_U [Ad 3c] GEMMER - Folds MAVERI9 - Folds SCHDNFRD - Folds PUNKIN_U - Raises $400 to $400 LEAVINGEGYPT - Folds GRAYCAT - Raises $600 to $600 BERGENISGAY - Folds TRUTHY - Folds EZ2PLY - Folds PUNKIN_U - Raises $400 to $800 GRAYCAT - Calls $200 *** FLOP *** [8d 6d Jh] PUNKIN_U - Bets $200 GRAYCAT - Raises $400 to $400 PUNKIN_U - Calls $200 *** TURN *** [8d 6d Jh] [2d] PUNKIN_U - Checks GRAYCAT - Checks *** RIVER *** [8d 6d Jh 2d] [7s] PUNKIN_U - Checks GRAYCAT - Checks *** SHOW DOWN *** PUNKIN_U - Shows [Ad 3c] (ace high) GRAYCAT - Mucks PUNKIN_U Collects $2695 from main pot *** SUMMARY *** Total Pot($2700) | Rake ($5) Board [8d 6d Jh 2d 7s] Seat 1: SCHDNFRD Folded on the POCKET CARDS Seat 2: PUNKIN_U won Total ($2695) HI$2695) with ace high [Ad 3c - P:Ad,B:Jh,B:8d,B:7s,B:6d] Seat 3: LEAVINGEGYPT Folded on the POCKET CARDS Seat 4: GRAYCAT HI: [Mucked] [Qh 9d] Seat 5: BERGENISGAY (dealer) Folded on the POCKET CARDS Seat 6: TRUTHY (small blind) Folded on the POCKET CARDS Seat 7: EZ2PLY (big blind) Folded on the POCKET CARDS Seat 8: GEMMER Folded on the POCKET CARDS Seat 9: MAVERI9 Folded on the POCKET CARDS On one hand, I won the pot, so, on that level, the hand itself is fine. On the other hand, you could say that, *had* an opponent decided to 3-bet me with Q9, then hypothetically most high stakes players would've lost more money post flop... So in a hand like this, should AP comp me another bet because most high stakes players would've either called a flop bet then called a turn bet OR they would've raised the flop and bet the turn (or bet the river if checking the turn and the river gets checked to them). Again, I think there's a lot of merit to what you're suggesting. I also think however, there's a lot of room for interpretation to it and it might be too difficult to administer other than merely offering a flat premium on top of whatever money was won/lost (like say offering a 15% bonus... so if you lost $10,000, they would actually reimburse you $11,500, etc). |
|
|