|
View Poll Results: What Price was it? | |||
$1-$30 | 24 | 36.36% | |
$30-$60 | 26 | 39.39% | |
$60+ | 16 | 24.24% | |
Voters: 66. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
There are two teams below, with pitchers excluded. You can't mix and match. You are a GM and you can take either TEAM A or TEAM B for the next 3 years. The question is simple, which team do you take? PS . I realize that the best two players at each position where not necessarily the ones picked - I mention this before anyone rags about....how come you don't have Joe Blow in left field?? Team A SS H Ramirez 2b Roberts 1b Mourneau 3b Rodriguez CF Granderson LF M Ramirez RF Ordonez C Varitek Team B SS Reyes 2B Palanco 1B Pujols 3B M Cabrera CF Suzuki LF Holliday RF Guerrero C Posada |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
At first glance i was gonna say A no doubt bc of the big name guys: arod, manny, and morneau (magglio too but not on the same level as these guys imo). The big names on B are pujols, vlad and cabrera/reyes. but palanco>roberts imo and also posada>varitek. then tack on ichiro and i think team b takes it. the big names on A are better but team B has more depth and te big names arent too shabby either.
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
Team B is equal or better at every single position.
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
[ QUOTE ]
Team B is equal or better at every single position. [/ QUOTE ] A-Rod isn't on team B. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] Team B is equal or better at every single position. [/ QUOTE ] A-Rod isn't on team B. [/ QUOTE ] Cabrera > A-Rod |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
SS: Reyes >> Ramirez, B
3B: Rodriguez >> Cabrera, A 2B: Roberts > Polanco, A 1B: Pujols > Morneau, B LF: Holliday > Ramirez, B CF: Suzuki >>> Granderson, B RF: Guerrero >> Ordonez, B C: Posada > Varitek, B B would win 21-5, with A-Rod going 5-for-5 with 5 solo HR. /thread |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
[ QUOTE ]
SS: Reyes >> Ramirez, B 3B: Rodriguez >> Cabrera, A 2B: Roberts > Polanco, A 1B: Pujols > Morneau, B LF: Holliday > Ramirez, B CF: Suzuki >>> Granderson, B RF: Guerrero >> Ordonez, B C: Posada > Varitek, B /thread [/ QUOTE ] I love when people make posts that are incredibly wrong and say /thread afterwards. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] SS: Reyes >> Ramirez, B 3B: Rodriguez >> Cabrera, A 2B: Roberts > Polanco, A 1B: Pujols > Morneau, B LF: Holliday > Ramirez, B CF: Suzuki >>> Granderson, B RF: Guerrero >> Ordonez, B C: Posada > Varitek, B /thread [/ QUOTE ] I love when people make posts that are incredibly wrong and say /thread afterwards. [/ QUOTE ] what exactly is incredibly wrong about my assesment? probably I exaggerated, rodriguez is only > cabrera, not >>, and same goes with reyes vs. ramirez, but the rest are accurate EDIT: I actually analyzed this on a one-game basis and I forgot about the 3 year thing, but hands down I take team B for the next 3 years |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
i'm of the opinion that ramirez > reyes, but that's just a small point. i'd take B
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Which of these two MLB teams would you you take?
Well the problem is with Reyes and Ramirez you created a baseline for what each of your > means.
Reyes and Ramirez are really close and you could flip it. If Hanley wasn't such a liability defensively it wouldn't be close. But for instance Reyes - Ramirez < Posada - Varitek I think Suzuki isn't >>> Granderson especially when you consider Granderson is getting better while Ichiro is getting worse. |
|
|