Last Train to Nowhere (Game thread)

[Spook]

[ QUOTE ]
spook

[/ QUOTE ]
does villager eskimo clear players? AS-something and MM:Luckay could refresh your memory.

[Mark_K]

I've been rereading spooks posts. I still think he's a wolf and his random voting pattern really points to him being a wolf. He made a very interesting quote early in the game:
[ QUOTE ]


Ok, since no one else has posted on it yet.
Pretend there are only two wolves in the game. A normal wolf, and a brutal wolf. If the normal wolf gets lynched, then the brutal wolf losses his ability to kill.
Obviously this can be a huge asset. Say that there are two seer candidates, and with 24/7 wolf chat, this is much easier to coordinate, but if the two regular wolves indite the brutal wolf, they get two shots at nk'ing a seer.

It didn't go antidan->Lastchance. It went antidan->nicholas->LC.

But there are three wolves. If neil died last night as a wolf, fcbl can't get outed and us the kill as successfully as a seer hunt. And village++ for whoever helped to lynch FCBL.


[/ QUOTE ]

Spook might be saying that the other wolf was on FCBL that night.. I Dunno.. We need to examine this path.

[Mark_K]

Here's my current Village/Wolf list:

Village
Mark

Lean Village
LuckayLuck
Siegmund
theSmell
Skoob

Neutral
Jonsan
clowntable
Eskimo

Lean Wolf
Quadstriker
Spook

Lean Cultist
dmk


The complete non-interaction between quad and Spook/FCBL is VERY interesting.... DMK HAS to be the other cultist.

[Lardarse]

<font color="red">NIGHT!

Spook is dead. He was a VILLAGER.

Night actions in by 8am, please.</font>

[Spook]

Wolves, send me your night action, and if Lardarse doesn't show up I will get this game started for tomorrow.

[Spook]

*************IT IS STILL NIGHT*****************
<font color="red">Luckay has died in the night, villager.

Day will start at 8 AM Tuesday morning EST pending something from Lardarse.</font>

I will not post a day post, as I will be asleep. Please mind the time and post away after 8AM.

Edit: To be perfectly clear, Luckay is the night kill, he and he alone won't wake up in the morning, I am just getting the information out before the day starts.

********IT IS STILL NIGHT************

[Lardarse]

<font color="red">It is now Day 5.

Luckay is dead. He was a VILLAGER.

You can start posting. Lynch will be at 9pm Eastern time.

Spook: Thanks for covering.</font>

[Mark_K]

With the day off I spent the time rereading the WHOLE thread (Yes, 1700 posts).
Using the NK's and thread reread and some thinking I have SERIOUSLY revamped my Village/Wolf list.

Here's my new list:

Village
Mark

Lean Village
theSmell
Jonsan
Quadstriker
Eskimo

Neutral
Siegmund

Lean Wolf
clowntable
Skoob

Lean Cultist
dmk

I think there are two wolves in the list Skoob/Clown/Sieg (most to least wolfy) and DMK is the cultist. The reason DMK is the cultist is due to the process of elimination (all the other people not voting Voj are dead except for Eskimo) and DMK's "unusual" voting history. He is the only person left that fits the cultist role.


All the Lean village people have Village-telled pretty well... (see Luckay's posts for examples)

I moved Siegmund to Neutral because his FCBL vote at the last minute can really be a wolf trying to pile on the FCBL lynch. However, he has made several insightful comments during the game. He is really here because the "Lean Village" group are even more villagery. I think FCBL really clears Quad with his D1 comment that Quad was around but not playing. I think it is REALLY tough for a wolf to make that exact comment about another wolf.

I have a arguement for Skoob-wolf that I'll post in a bit...

The village gets one mislynch then we are at must-lynch time.

If all of the evils exist in the above four and we lynch these four, the village wins.

[Mark_K]

Skoob is a wolf because:

During the last hour of the day FCBL got lynched (Neil was the other BW), who was begging Lardarse for a countif?? Yes, Skoob... Here are Skoob's quotes over a 10 min period:

FCBL BW builds:
[ QUOTE ]

It would be nice to see the vote count right about now


[/ QUOTE ]

After more votes for FCBL:
[ QUOTE ]

Fo realz - where's lardares with a count for cripes sake?


[/ QUOTE ]

Finally:
[ QUOTE ]

Somebody kick lardarse in the balls and wake his ass up.


[/ QUOTE ]
Note: Skoob wasn't the leading, 2nd leading or 3rd leading BW. (FCBL, Neil, and LC were...)

Why is Scoob SO INTERESTED in FCBL's vote count?

The next day after LC was NC'ed, Scoob posted this little dandy:

[ QUOTE ]

And I has a question. Is it just totally brilliant that the wolves killed both seers nights 1 and 2? Or are they lucky?

Did Dan and LC make too obvious posts?

Is it safe to assume that at least one of the remaining wolves is really, really good?


[/ QUOTE ]

THEN he makes this response to Siegmund, responding to this quote:
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

Hard to tell if they were lucky or good (or had some personal read) to get lastchance.

I can't help but point out that this "gee, the wolves must be really good/experienced players" is coming from a newbie who is being accused of being a wolf. Just a tiny bit self-serving?


[/ QUOTE ]
It would only be self-serving if I were a wolf.


[/ QUOTE ]


This was an interesting "insight" that Skoob brought up and then the "If I were a wolf" answer just seems very wolfy...

BTW, I looked at the village-tell Luckay said that Skoob gave D1 by voting himself. Do you know what? Other than for dramatics, Skoob wasn't the leading two BW's anymore. (it was Voj and I).

vote skoob

[dmk]

siegmund yo