Farve:Madden as Reyes:Morgan

[grando]

Schneids: PokerBob is the best one methinks

[THAY3R]

[ QUOTE ]

Reyes has only had one really good year - not just in the majors, but his whole life

[/ QUOTE ]

This is just wrong. Reyes had excellent 2001 and 2002 Minor League seasons, and then in 2003 got called up.

You're acting like this guy is ancient, he's only 23!

[jalapenoguy]

[ QUOTE ]
A better analogy would be Jeter:McCarver

[/ QUOTE ]

morgan is just getting started. the reason i brought up the madden thing is that favre is one of the best ever at his position but still doesn't deserve the dicksucking madden gives him.

morgan brought up reyes 5-6 different times durring the red sox royals game today. his worthless analysis combined with reyes slobbing has put him as maddens equal.

[THEOSU]

brett favre is a great football player because he makes great football plays.

[Degenerasian]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

Reyes has only had one really good year - not just in the majors, but his whole life

[/ QUOTE ]

This is just wrong. Reyes had excellent 2001 and 2002 Minor League seasons, and then in 2003 got called up.

You're acting like this guy is ancient, he's only 23!

[/ QUOTE ]

ok its a bit of an exaggeration, but there are people less hyped who have put up better stats than Reyes pre-2006

[THEOSU]

Jose Reyes is a great baseball player because he makes great baseball plays.

[THAY3R]

Yes, but Reyes Pre-2006 was <= 21 years old lol.

[Degenerasian]

every minor leaguer/MLB prospect has been more or less under a microscope since they leave high school (about 17 yrs old), and a lot of them during HS yet they still put up ridiculous stats

EDIT: in no way am i calling JR a one-year wonder, I'm just saying that Pre-2006 the east coast bias and the NY media hype machine helped make a lot of people believe reyes was better than he actually was...no doubt he has improved