Melinda vs. Lakisha - thoughts

[GrannyMae]

[ QUOTE ]
some more on my thoughts---

season 1: best top 6 singer: tamrya winner: Kelly
season 2: best: Kim Locke: winner: Rueben
season 3: best: Jennifer H. winner: Fantasia
season 4: best: carrie winner: carrie
season 5; best: chris: winner: taylor

the key to advances is to sing your style better than anyone else

[/ QUOTE ]

tamarya? kim locke? jen h?

not.

all of these voices were 3rd-6th+ best imo.

[curtains]

[ QUOTE ]
some more on my thoughts---

season 1: best top 6 singer: tamrya winner: Kelly
season 2: best: Kim Locke: winner: Rueben
season 3: best: Jennifer H. winner: Fantasia
season 4: best: carrie winner: carrie
season 5; best: chris: winner: taylor

the key to advances is to sing your style better than anyone else

[/ QUOTE ]

I believe that Latoya London was definitely better than Hudson. I think she was far and away the best pure singer of the season and maybe in American Idol history.