MISH-MASH MAFIA I (game thread)

[xorbie]

if the cop has a mafia, now is a good time to come out. worst case scenario, we have two masons, but that still leaves us with a doctor, a martyr or a backup cop.

by the way bucsno1, i think you are missing the fact that shortline was probably a traitor. i think it's quite possible that there is no miller or godfather, and so the cop's information is very likely to be accurate at this point.

[Bucsno1]

I see no reason not to lynch rbdog. I am not really sure on others, waiting to see how discussion goes at this point but rbdog has made terrible posts today.

[Bucsno1]

Also, I sort of messed up with my numbers because of the suiciding. The chances are not out of 15 they are out of 13. I believe the rest was right. The main point of course was the fact that the cop can see 2 mafia or 4 mafia depending on the special roles.

[Bucsno1]

[ QUOTE ]
if the cop has a mafia, now is a good time to come out. worst case scenario, we have two masons, but that still leaves us with a doctor, a martyr or a backup cop.

by the way bucsno1, i think you are missing the fact that shortline was probably a traitor. i think it's quite possible that there is no miller or godfather, and so the cop's information is very likely to be accurate at this point.

[/ QUOTE ]

If there was a traitor then yes my numbers are wrong. I guess that kind of makes my posts useless. Still I think it is important to remember the roles. I apologize to the people reading my posts thinking why is this kid sooo dumb.

[xorbie]

nevermind you got it.

speak up minions.

[MDoranD]

[ QUOTE ]
nevermind you got it.

speak up minions.

[/ QUOTE ]

Home from work now. All Hail Zaxbys!

[xorbie]

all,

we should figure out what happened last night also. i want a clarification from the mod:

if the mafia targeted me, and i was hit by the flying pumping, this could prevent me from getting eaten right?

[VoraciousReader]

King Xorbie,

This is how I started to sort things:

Pro-Mafia Roles: (should be 2)
terrorist (deceased Greekhouse)
traitor (????Shortline????)
miller
godfather

Case for Shortline as traitor: saved by a mafia member, tried to divert votes from tokyo, went full-out for GH, who while pro-Mafia, would have looked innocent to a traitor. But he tried to divert from Tokyo onto vox. Now that we are certain vox is another mafia member, that looks less suspicious. Also, being saved by Tokyo is not compelling evidence for Shorty as traitor...because the mafia doesn't know who the traitor is. I think the mafia was perfectly happy to let us kill Shorty the first day just to get a villager, but saw an opportunity to take out wdc, a much stronger player, and did so.

On balance, I don't find this compelling. So I think we need to strongly consider that there may still be a hidden pro-Mafia out there.

Neutral: Pumpkin, obvious.

Pro-Village:

After last night, it's tempting to say that we still have a doctor, at least. I think this is the most likely scenario. Again, though, what if the mafia tried to kill xorbie? If the pumpkin hit him with the king for a day thing, would he have been kept alive for that?

I don't think the village can afford to relax here.

[Madtown]

xorbie,

Theoretically, that is a possibility.

[VoraciousReader]

I guess I post too slow.