*Official* Philadelphia E-A-G-L-E-S Thread (2007-2008)

[SMIGLET]

i have to say in this mcnabb vs garcia argument that its not really who was better, clearly mcnabb is more talented, garcia more accurate. Rather its the system that they play in. Garcia is very very good in the west coast offense, which is why he did so well with san fran, then so bad with cleveland/detroit, and then well again with philly and now tampa bay. mcnabb needs to be in a run and gun type of offense, hes really good at making the big plays, but lacks overall consistency. for that reason i think hed do very well in a place like new orleans with sean payton or in new england with belechik. unfortunately for mcnabb not too many teams run such an offense.