"Un-mucking" a mucked hand

[RR]

[ QUOTE ]
First off, she mucked her hand. Shouldn't it be dead the second it touches the muck, unless swept into the muck by dealer error?

[/ QUOTE ]
no



[ QUOTE ]
Second off, it wasn't even clearly identifiable in the muck,

[/ QUOTE ]

It looks like it was since the dealer knew where it was.

The dealer should not be doing this without a floor there. From the description it sounds like she might not have made a claim for the pot, but I know people often tell these stories in a way that advances the decision they want.