**American Idol The Top 3

[jar]

[ QUOTE ]
yea see i actually like the song but her version sucked IMO. I know I'm in the minority here but i just cant see what the big deal is...i actually made a cringing face while she was singing.

The best song I thought she did all year was the Cherry Tree song, because she wasn't trying to be a diva (which she isn't)

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree. During the whole a capella part at the beginning, I was thinking let's see how far off pitch she is when the band comes in. Sounded like it took her a bit to get back once they came in. Also, I cringed on nearly every big note. Kat just doesn't have the 'big note' diva voice, much as she wants to. I think the Cherry Tree song was my favorite of hers as well.