[posnera]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
You should star yourself for the stupidest question ever. He GAVE her the ring. That makes it HERS. It would still be hers if SHE had cheated on HIM, although a classy cheating whore would then give it back.

[/ QUOTE ]

So if I'm given a 4 year scholarship to a University and I fail out of school the 1st semester, I am entitled to ~$50,000?

Or would you argue that the Scholarship is just a gift, that, get this, *has conditions*?

[/ QUOTE ]

A better analogy would be getting a scholarship and having the college close after the first year. You would not be entitled to compensation for the next three years.

I take all my quasi-legal advice from Judge Judy. She always makes the girl give the ring back. It is a gift in anticipation of marriage. There is no issue with who's fault it is. (but maybe that is California law and is different in other states)