1-2NL FOR THE SAKE OF ARGUMENT

[MyPTBB100isPOOP]

Assume you made the mistake of getting involved with this hand in this fashion, vs a 24/18, agressive opener. Assume he bets at least 50% of his range on this flop, which is prob like 66+,A5s+,K9s+,Q9s+,J9s+,ATo+,KTo+,QTo+. For the sake of argument, is a call better, or a raise better and why do you believe so? I think a raise is best because it will FOLD OUT ALL THE HANDS WE BEAT. OR is it best equity wise to wait for a blank to fall on the turn, have it check to us so we can bet and fold out hands that we beat?

SB: $323.15
BB: $187.00
UTG: $148.70
CO: $199.00
Hero (BTN): $227.90

Preflop: Hero is dealt Ad2d(5 Players)
UTG folds, CO raises to $8.00, Hero calls $8.00, SB folds, BB calls $6.00

Flop: ($25) 3c9cAc (3 Players)
BB folds, CO bets $17.00, Hero.....

[kolotoure]

How is making a raise where every worse hand folds and every better hand calls a good idea?

[MyPTBB100isPOOP]

[ QUOTE ]
How is making a raise where every worse hand folds and every better hand calls a good idea?

[/ QUOTE ]

this is the point that i wanted to argue about, but i want a few others to chime in first. Its something i thought alot about last night, and it has to do with these kind of board textures. Give it some thought, but im convinced its a good thing......

[amoeba]

I'm more questioning of your read that he bets 50% of his holdings on this monotone multiway flop.

[HERE_2_gamble_]

so its clear, when he(someone) shoves, whadda ya do?

[MyPTBB100isPOOP]

[ QUOTE ]
I'm more questioning of your read that he bets 50% of his holdings on this monotone multiway flop.

[/ QUOTE ]

Although thats not the point of this argument, I can certainly see an aggressive opener raising 36% and firing a cbet with 100% of his range on any flop. I think that would be close to standard. Especially if he concieves it likely that my cc range on the button is like 90% likely to be pps and Suitedcons.

[Unknown Soldier]

you make money by getting the hands that you beat to CALL your bet/raise.

[MyPTBB100isPOOP]

[ QUOTE ]
you make money by getting the hands that you beat to CALL your bet/raise.

[/ QUOTE ]

This is of course the stock logic, and id say in most situations that its the most +EV way to think of it. However me posing this question, in my mind, presupposes that i already understand that concept, but am alluding to a different one.

[MyPTBB100isPOOP]

to make it easier, assume that we can only call or raise in the hand we are talking about, that is important.

[ttgirl]

no way hes cbetting 50% of his range here. i guess raising is better so bb doesnt get direct odds to draw with like the jack of clubs or something, but this is just a terrible spot to be in. obviously were not raising for value but to protect our hand here.