Old-Timers Game (GAME THREAD)

[ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S]

i will change if everyone agrees that if those peeks change/are shown wrong we turbo lynch him and ignore anything he says.

[shortline99]

we're already ignoring everything he says, but obviously we let him keep talking and eventually we decide to lynch him if we think we're running out of wolf suspects.

[ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S]

dont ignore claimed seers should be about 100x more important than dont lynch claimed seers imo.

[shortline99]

no, you should absolutely ignored claimed seers as long as they live

[Spook]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
vote mets

[/ QUOTE ]

Nice to see you have so many opinions and are following the thread closely.

[/ QUOTE ]

patrick
going to bed. hopefully tomorrow is a new day.

[Stephen H]

Okay I'm caught up and I think we could use an updated vote count - I'm going to try to put something together so I can see where we stand.

[Stephen H]

My unoffical count:
1 Bobo -- mets
2 boiler -- mets
0 chim -- duffy
0 chuckles -- patton
0 dmk -- boiler
0 eskimo -- bobo
1 fish -- traz
0 IY -- kumu
2 kumu -- patton
0 KM -- mets
5 mets -- boiler
0 mostsmooth -- fish
0 nich -- mets
0 oh -- duffy
7 duffy -- patton
3 patton -- duffy
0 shorty -- duffy
0 spook -- duffy
0 stephen -- kumu
0 tokyo -- mets
2 traz -- duffy
0 vr -- duffy
0 xorbie -- traz

It appears this is coming down to Mets/Duffy which seems reasonable given a lot of the talk today. I have Duffy as more wolfy than mets by quite a lot right now.

The following people aren't on either of the top 2 wagons and need to figure out if they like either of those as a wolf and vote one of 'em:
chuck/dmk/eskimo/fish/IY/kumu/mets/mostsmooth/duffy/xorbie
Mets, Duffy, I recommend voting each other. If you think the other is a villager, then work together to start a 3rd candidate.

Vote Duffy for 8 votes on Duffy.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
ok guys im reading through now, when something pops out at me ill reply to it

Stephen H -

[ QUOTE ]
Okay I haven't evaluated everyone but my wolf list is filling out nicely. In some rough order:

Mets
Boiler
Kumu
KM
Xorbie
Duffy
Eskimo

I'd be happiest with a mets/boiler/kumu lynch today.

[/ QUOTE ]

would love to know why im on this list.

[/ QUOTE ]

I went to go answer this and realized I don't actually know. My notes (slim as they are) are on another computer and I don't have them right now. I went to go read your posts as that's what I was doing when I wrote that list - reading people's posts and determining if I should put them on my wolf list - and I found that I *hadn't* read your posts earlier today. So there must have been some mistake, although I clearly remember thinking at some point "Yea, Eskimo is a wolf suspect" although from there every time I added a suspect they were more suspicious than you.

So, short answer is "I dunno"

Notice, please, that my list has been refined over the course of the day. KM and you are not on it anymore, and mets has moved down. Patton was added to the list fairly highly but has slid down as well over the day. He's still on it, though.

[ESKiMO-SiCKNE5S]

there is no majority so i dont think we need to assume those are the 2 wagons just yet, this day could stretch out another week if we need it to

of duffy and mets, i think duffy is more likely to be wolfia, but mets tells us more due to bobo

so mets i guess

[VoraciousReader]

eskimo, this is NOT that other ww site. One week day is not happening.

If you think duffy is a wolf, vote him above mets, please.

Informational lynches are generally bad but there is a place for them. That place is not now and they are PARTICULARLY bad in this situation.

Remember, we get an avalanche of information: as soon as we LYNCH SOMEONE.

The faster we lynch someone today, the quicker we can kill traz tomorrow when he's still alive.