David Wright got screwed

[Neuge]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Precisely my intrinsic point. The award, if they're going to have one, should properly reflect what it is supposed to stand for. Right now, it does not.

Wright was the best all-around player in the NL in 2007.

That's all.

[/ QUOTE ]

By Wright you actually mean Holliday, right? How valuable can you be if you cant even lead your teams to the playoffs?

[/ QUOTE ]

Very? Unless you want me to bust out "How useful can you be when you cant even lead your team to winning the WS since we all know there are only two outcomes in a baseball season, first and not-first." Valuable means helping your team win games. Helping a 50 win team win 70 games is valuable, even if they dont make the playoffs. Helping a 90 win team win 91 is less valuable, even if that win happens to get you into the playoffs that particular year.

The other unfortunate conclusion to be drawn from your argument is that it is basically impossible for any of the Indians or Red Sox to have been MVP because they would have made the playoffs without any one guy, and the wins after clinching the playoffs are value-less right?

[/ QUOTE ]
But Holliday literally ate dirt to get his team into the playoffs. You don't think that's valuable?