AFI Top 50 Movie Stars

[andyfox]

Just wondering what stars who didn't qualify, because their careers didn't start by 1950, would now make the list and what stars would be bumped. Here are the lists:

1. Humphrey Bogart Katharine Hepburn
2. Cary Grant Bette Davis
3. James Stewart Audrey Hepburn
4. Marlon Brando Ingrid Bergman
5. Fred Astaire Greta Garbo
6. Henry Fonda Marilyn Monroe
7. Clark Gable Elizabeth Taylor
8. James Cagney Judy Garland
9. Spencer Tracy Marlene Dietrich
10. Charles Chaplin Joan Crawford
11. Gary Cooper Barbara Stanwyck
12. Gregory Peck Claudette Colbert
13. John Wayne Grace Kelly
14. Laurence Olivier Ginger Rogers
15. Gene Kelly Mae West
16. Orson Welles Vivien Leigh
17. Kirk Douglas Lillian Gish
18. James Dean Shirley Temple
19. Burt Lancaster Rita Hayworth
20. The Marx Brothers Lauren Bacall
21. Buster Keaton Sophia Loren
22. Sidney Poitier Jean Harlow
23. Robert Mitchum Carole Lombard
24. Edward G. Robinson Mary Pickford
25. William Holden Ava Gardner

Which of the following stars would you put on the list? Any I've left out?

Males:
Clint Eastwood
Paul Newman
Robert Redford
Tom Cruise
Tom Hanks
Jack Nicholson
Al Pacino
Robert De Niro
Dustin Hoffman
Russell Crowe
Denzel Washington
Leonardo DiCaprio
Anthony Hopkins
Steve McQueen
Harrison Ford

Females:
Meryl Streep
Nicole Kidman
Julia Roberts
Jodie Foster

[MediaPA]

Hmm, Gene Hackman, Morgan Freeman, Ed Norton, Johnny Depp would probably be worthy of consideration now or in the future.

For women, Kiera Knightly depending on how her career unfolds in the future. Natalie Portman would also fit into this category.

Just a few nominations.

[B00T]

Joe Pesci, Sylvester Stallone, Tom Hanks for sure.. Adam Sandler could be a reach depending on what the list is based off of

Meg Ryan, Kim Bassinger for sure.

[ClassicBob]

Edit: I'm dumb

[mrbaseball]

Jack Lemmon (TV before 1950 but no movies)
Michael Douglass
Jeff Bridges
Arnold Schwartzenager
John Travolta
James Colburn
Matt Damon
Bruce Willis
Dean Martin
Jerry Lewis (Martin and Lewis started right around 1950 I think)
Jane Fonda

Not saying these folks should be on the list (sans Lemmon) but they probably deserve consideration due to "stardom".

James Dean? Guy was only in 3 movies and none before 1950? He shouldn't qualify because of that? I guess body of work and range isn't a consideration?

[Jeff W]

Newman, Nicholson, Lemmon, De Niro

[sethypooh21]

Sean Penn
If he keeps going, maybe Viggo Mortenson (LoTR, Perfect Murder, History of Violence, and I'm told he's phenomenal in Eastern Promises)
Sean [censored] Connery?
Jeff Bridges
John Goodman
Steve Buscemi
John Turtorro
PS Hoffman (yeah I just went Lebowski there, but look how strong the cast of that movie is...)

Charlize Theron
Frances McDormand

[Moneyball16]

Kevin Spacey.