Need NYC dining rec

[LyinKing]

I know there are several similar threads at the moment, but this is a specific request; I don't dine much around MSG, which is where I'll be Sunday evening. Several places I do know are in fact closed Sundays. So I'm looking for a good place for a party of 5, Italian or interesting American/contintental. Want to be within immediate walking distance from the Garden, that is the low/west 20s means too far. Any suggestions? Much obliged.