LOTR: Return of the King (GAME THREAD)

[Thebram]

What a coincidence, I want to go chuckles or stephen today.
I'm sure saying that alone will sign my death warrant, as they are likely to be the most vocal about the lynch, but it is what it is.

Sorry that, unlike chuckles, I dont have a fake "whoa is me, poor village" comment that doesnt help at all, to throw in at the end of my post.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
I think I want Bram or fmxda today. Fmxda has been much more helpful than he was in ASXII. Since all the good power roles are taken care of, I think that makes him evill. Also, I have this bad feeling one of fcbl or fortfun is godfather. That alone is the reason Jack and nez shouldn't of come out.

[/ QUOTE ]

fmxda? Really? I think it's Jeremy/Bram and fmxda is a distant third choice. I'll try reading fmxda again but honestly I don't expect to find anything.

[chuckleslovakian]

fmxda is because he wasn't helpful at all in ASXI when he was a villager. Then in CYOA I thought he was being more thoughtful than he was in ASXI. Sure enough he was wolf then.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
Hm, after Herbie dies I'll take on the mantle of leadership and crusade against gt1t the wolf


... unless Herbie comes up wolf


... which he won't

[/ QUOTE ]

I read through fmxda days ago and this jumped out as very wolfy to me. However, with Herbie being a wolf, this is actually villagery. It would be pretty gutsy to say this as a wolf partner with Herbie and not-wolf GT1T.
Obviously I should skim CYOA at this point to see if I'm reading fmxda wolfstyle right.

[chuckleslovakian]

heres an important thing. Just search ASXI for fmxdas posts. you dont even to read them. Just note he only posted 44 times in that game.

[fmxda]

[ QUOTE ]
fmxda is because he wasn't helpful at all in ASXI when he was a villager. Then in CYOA I thought he was being more thoughtful than he was in ASXI. Sure enough he was wolf then.

[/ QUOTE ]
By the end of CYOA I was pretty unhelpful there too.

Do I really push Herbie and clowntable all game if I am a wolf? I would have thought that that alone would be clearing me right now... I guess being wrong on RichC./Zurvan2 was what didn't get me nightkill and what is still leaving doubt in your minds.

Keep in mind doing an about face on Herbie from d1->d2 is pretty unlikey for a wolf to do, as well as insisting that you, chuckles is a villager, for two days straight, when both days had wolves as the other bandwagon.

I think doing some bandwagon analysis on the nights the wolves died/were pushed will be very helpful.

I will write up a big post about that later today.

[fmxda]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Hm, after Herbie dies I'll take on the mantle of leadership and crusade against gt1t the wolf


... unless Herbie comes up wolf


... which he won't

[/ QUOTE ]

I read through fmxda days ago and this jumped out as very wolfy to me. However, with Herbie being a wolf, this is actually villagery. It would be pretty gutsy to say this as a wolf partner with Herbie and not-wolf GT1T.
Obviously I should skim CYOA at this point to see if I'm reading fmxda wolfstyle right.

[/ QUOTE ]
Might I add that I said this towards the end of d1.

After d1 I did a complete 180 and my top suspects became RichC. and Herbie.

[Stephen H]

[ QUOTE ]
heres an important thing. Just search ASXI for fmxdas posts. you dont even to read them. Just note he only posted 44 times in that game.

[/ QUOTE ]

That's an activity tell, not a helpfulness tell. And after some searching I see some games where he was relatively quiet as a wolf (Dungeon 2) and relatively chatty for a villager (Lunar Legend - 58 posts in 4 days). So I'm not ready to condemn him based on him being active.

[Stephen H]

fmxda has been drilling wolves all game - herbie, clown, even TFG when he got lynched. I'm not voting him.

[Stephen H]

I just read all of Jeremy's posts and I'm more comfortable than ever with

Voting Jeremy now

and bram tomorrow.