Would love some Feedback please:

[Fishonaquest]

Make it a four colour deck. Apart from that I really like the idea and I'm sure I'm gonna use this site (in case I'm able to import HH correctly)...

[Gonso]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Yeah, even when you fix all of the problems I'm not sure I see anything new here

[/ QUOTE ]

Thank you for the kind words [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

One thing because of the structure is simply the intelligence, so we'd know what types of hands win or lose.

One other feature we were thinking about is basically player tracking. So if you had the room up in front of you, you'd be able to see what type of player the people you are up against, how they normally play etc.

Not that interesting to you?

[/ QUOTE ]

I wasn't posting to give you "kind words." You posted here asking for some feedback, and I took the time to look through your site and give you some feedback. I'm sorry if it wasn't the praise you were hoping for, but it was honest. Frankly, I think I was pretty nice about it considering it's got several major bugs.

You can't expect the posters here to evaluate things that you're considering doing in the future. Also, regarding the count of hands that win, that's available, and it's somewhat misleading when interpreted improperly.

[goofyballer]

10 second evaluation: Work on the bugs first, then ask opinions.

[N 82 50 24]

I like the idea and some of the things about the site...

-web 2.0 interface
-good urls
-the xml standardization effort

I don't really like the replayer or the cards. I also don't see why you make the account pages password protected, those pages should have a listen of hands posted by that account.

All in all, a better pokerhand.org is a long-awaited good idea. This just isn't there yet.