Hacker Attack (All Info Game Thread - Feb 19 Start)

[jjhender]

Right now I'm trying to wrap my mind around the peek information. At this point its a little difficult to use though since there a 7 rogues polluting any information that could be gathered from it.

For reference, this is current:



Any corrections, let me know.

Also, I have no idea what dan is trying to accomplish with his lists, other than to try to steer people into Good/Evil categories which IMO can't be done reliably with 1/3 of our information fake.

This is a list of how many times the people remaining in the game have been peeked. I used countif, so hopefully I didn't mess up on any of the names in the grid:

amplify 7
antidan 5
fnord 5
happy/nez 0
herbie 0
jeremy 2
jjhender 1
kbar 1
kyro 6
luckay 6
neil 8
nich 3
stephen 14
traz 12
thebram 3
TFG 2
Voj 0
wdcbooks 7
xoom 3
Xorbie 2
Zurvan 6

I'm also curious if there is any significance in how many times someone has been peeked. Its possible that the rogues are avoiding naming each other in their lists, but I don't really know how likely that is.

[jjhender]

Just noticed one error, nez was peeked once by antidan.

[jjhender]

***DISCLAIMER***

I think it is a terrible idea to use this count as a basis for lynching. Anyone's specific peeks must be used in context to have the best chance of nailing a rogue. I put this together because I feel there is information out there that may or may not be intentionally misleading.

***/DISCLAIMER***

[Neil S]

I think the only thing these distribution charts tell us, is who's more likely to be getting fake peeked, and even that's a stretch since if enough people get peeked often, there will be some outliers with uneven distributions.

[jjhender]

That is quite possible. I see what antidan's trying to do here, and I'm just getting any information I can out there. Not that I don't like his contributions in this game, but coming up with a list based on 1/3 of the people in the game as normal seers isn't particularly convincing.

[wdcbooks]

I think what Dan is doing is very valuable. It can be misinterpreted, but he certainly isn't doing that, he is just providing the information.

I am voting Luckay even though it appears that I am supposed to be going next for whatever reason.

[TruFloridaGator]

Luckay

[Voj]

BTW, I was just thinking about :
Could someone please peek Herbie and me ?

Right now, wolves are more and more likely to night kill those who haven't been peeked as our death (mine for sure I'm villaseer) won't release any information to the village...

[Stephen H]

I thought about luckay and took a nap and decided that the best course of action today is probably
Zurvan.

Now I'm going to get lunch and go to the park and I'll think some more.

[kbar13]

change to luckay I'm not getting a wolfy vibe from neil right now