what do you say

[Aloysius]

[ QUOTE ]
If she's genuinely not bone, kate moss skinny, she probably thinks she's fat

[/ QUOTE ]

Is that really true? Most of the time I've been asked this question by women who are 1) clearly not fat by any normal standard and 2) reasonably attractive to above-average.

Meaning struck me as a thing where they were randomly feeling insecure for whatever reason, and fishing for compliments.

Haha actually, do overweight to fat chicks ever ask this question? They know they are fat, yah?

-Al

[siccjay]

[ QUOTE ]
When my wife says it, I roll my eyes and say "You're NOT fat!" And that's it. That's all she wants to hear.

If some girl you're after says it, act genuinely confused. "What are you talking about? You're not fat..."

[/ QUOTE ]

This is what you should NOT do.

[tuq]

[ QUOTE ]
Haha actually, do overweight to fat chicks ever ask this question? They know they are fat, yah?

[/ QUOTE ]
True, but they can take solace in the fact that they have a long career in human resources ahead of them.

[mbillie1]

Just look disgusted and say "What am I, a personal trainer? I don't [censored] know. Since we've stopped talking about me I have found you very uninteresting. Get naked or something."

Alternately, use some bloodninja chat, a la "I pry apart the battleship you call your ass..."

[MacGuyV]

[ QUOTE ]
look her up and down, and say, "i'd still hit it"

how gay is it to add a jackass response to my own thread?

[/ QUOTE ]

Perfectly acceptable imo.

[MegaloMialo]

If she is a bit fat, tell her, she would like to know.

[ddss6_99]

Most girls who say those things are not fat, know that they aren't fat, and are just fishing for you to tell them they're not fat in order to boost their pathetic self esteem.