LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[Neil S]

You guys didn't need a hobbit seer anyway. Between nicking Merry/Pippin early, seeing through Nich right away, finding Frodo when you did, and the day/night you got Traz, it'd have been a travesty if you lost.

[TruFloridaGator]

I understood why some didn't switch off of me obviously but it was just compounded by the fact that VR wasn't around & someone was voting for neither GT1T or me. I did understand, I was just a bit flabbergasted, but then I realized how well it could work out.

[TruFloridaGator]

[ QUOTE ]
oh ok -- not wolfchat - just out of thread communication with another player (and private), but not the same at all as what i did

[/ QUOTE ]

I talked to sighing before I did, he saw what I was saying in the chat.

[sighing]

[ QUOTE ]
Dark should have won that in a rout though. I <3 your games sighing, but they tend to be just a wee bit villager bias.

[/ QUOTE ]
I designed this one about 55/45 to favor the wolves.

It's not my fault that (a) the wolves sacrificed Sauron on Day 1, and (b) the wolves had the angel AND Sam out on Day 3 and decided not to kill either.

[soah]

[ QUOTE ]
oh ok -- not wolfchat - just out of thread communication with another player (and private), but not the same at all as what i did

[/ QUOTE ]

you're right, they are not the same at all. you cheated and I didn't

[sighing]

Econo got a strong warning for that post. If he'd actually had a peek on Luckay at that point it would've been an instant modkill. Anyone doing something like that in one of my games (or hopefully anyone's games) in the future will be modkilled without futher warning.

Btw, TFG also made a post like that in another game thread (that nichp was an obvious villager) after he was dead.

[sighing]

One-way communication is fine. Soah can talk to a dead wolf, as long as the wolf isn't responding...

[soah]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Dark should have won that in a rout though. I <3 your games sighing, but they tend to be just a wee bit villager bias.

[/ QUOTE ]
I designed this one about 55/45 to favor the wolves.

It's not my fault that (a) the wolves sacrificed Sauron on Day 1, and (b) the wolves had the angel AND Sam out on Day 3 and decided not to kill either.

[/ QUOTE ]

we killed one seer before he gave out any clear peeks, converted the convertible character, killed two other power roles, knew the identities of two more power roles, got 4 villagers lynched in the first 5 days, blocked the other seer twice, and we were hanging on for dear life to stay in the game at all.

[sighing]

Oh, one interesting point -

The night Merry and Pippin died, before anyone's roles were exposed, Aaronk protected Herbie, VR blocked Aaron, and the wolves ate Herbie.

I don't think I've ever seen that happen in a game.

[Zurvan]

afs;lkheaogiuhaoaskl jadjshgak jhalsa;di1f asdlkj asldihga gha;lkda

I'm so disgusted with this game I want to barf. I was still not completely sold on who to lynch this morning, but killing me instead of nez made it 100% obvious it was lastchance. Never in a million years does Stephen do that.

Just like the IY kill made it obvious it was soah, not me.

Blindly lynching people to sort out the day 1 wagons was terrible terrible terrible.

Traz going off like that when he was the seer was obscene.

Nich leading the village around by the nose, when a simple fake peek would have cleared econ from being frodo. Yes, fake peeks are bad, and normally I would say there's no excuse. This one situation is an exception, IMO, because the fake peek could be cleared up if nich dies that night.