Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
I say masons because Monk started the epi ball rolling and you picked it right after him.

[/ QUOTE ]

That's pretty weak.

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

youre "thoughts" sum up to 0. basically your thoughts were that dan is either a wolf or not a wolf, luckay was probably a pumpkin victim, and you didnt know what to think of herbie. monk was suggesting he was a sk/vig, so his silence makes sense? why does it make sense?
i didnt see epicrus claim, so i was doing what i felt was best.
you seem awfully sure epicrus isnt a wolf. odd.

[/ QUOTE ]

Not true, you word twisting howler.

I thought I pointed out several useful (and maybe obvious) things...

1. There exists a Good/neutral Flying Pumpkin. (BTW, this was before I even realised the existance of two pumpkins)
2. AntiDan could be evil and still be silenced (FWIW, I lean village on Dan)
3. I don't have a big epiphany on the Herbie kill.
4. That Monk could be silenced by a villager because he hinted that he was bad for the village.

I think all of these are good points and are the conclusions that I personally got from the night actions.

[/ QUOTE ]

The bolded part, now that chuck is a dead villager, makes Mark more suspicious even though the rest of the post seems pretty clean.

[antidan444]

This is interesting. Mark really went after chuck big time. And it looks bad in hindsight. But his tone for the most part feels pretty good to me. So I can't decide whether he's a villager who thought he had a good read on/case against chuck and it turned out wrong, or if he's a wolf who managed to get chuck lynched.

His tying chuck and monk together via masonry is probably the most alarming thing.

[clowntable]

Dan that is truely awesome [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img]

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
chuckles, i hope youve noticed mark and fmx's lack of complete explanation for why they think boiler is not a good lynch, and also how both said nothing else after..

at this point i would lynch any of the 3

[/ QUOTE ]

Complete info?

Hmm, Let's see... Do I think Boiler is a good lynch? Who knows? He pushed a villager (Epi) and Monk (wolf). Does that make him the best lynch for the day? No way, we have much better wolf candidates.

On the other hand we have Monk, playing switch the votes at day 1 nightfall. Trival question: Who put the TIEING vote on Nez on Day 1? Answer: Monk! A snipe at the last sec (literally) Also, Monk has been anti-village this whole game. Just ask Epi... Does wolf-Monk make today's role claim? Yep, everytime.

In conjunction with this train of thought, I don't mind an OH lynch. Monk did protect him after all... Plus OH has been talking about how he can't be lynched. I would like to test this theory....

The way Books is pushing me without giving ANY reasons is also suspect.

Chuck pick any one of the three. And I would love your "protection".

[/ QUOTE ]

See, this post feels all kinds of villagery to me.

[antidan444]

All in all, 1 being wolfy and 10 being villagery I'd give Mark a 6.

I can't see any way either boiler or mark is a better lynch than FMX at this point.

[antidan444]

But no matter what Monk is I can understand him wanting to go after Mark here.

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
Dan that is truely awesome [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img]

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm not quite sure which part was awesome, but thanks [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[antidan444]

I'm hoping FMX and OH are both evil, at which point I will really have to take a good long look at Monk.

If FMX is a villager I will throw up.

[Bulletproof Monk]

[ QUOTE ]
But no matter what Monk is I can understand him wanting to go after Mark here.

[/ QUOTE ]

honestly, the only reasons i can give anyone for suspecting me are:

a) biased because i tilted them (you)
b) not paying any attention (clown)
c) completely retarded
d) a wolf

past experience has taught me that neither boiler or mark are retarded. therefore they are both wofls