Star Trek: The Next Generation 2 (GAME THREAD) - Page 352

HerbieGRD · #**3511** 02-01-2007, 04:36 PM

[ QUOTE ]
sorry, I wasn't clear, are you saying that it is evidence to consider zurvan, or someone else?

[/ QUOTE ]
It is evidence that Zurvan is the Borg since he wouldn't ever FPS like that as a villager

Zurvan · #**3512** 02-01-2007, 04:48 PM

Herbie:

Read the second last day of Star Wars.

I will keep things from the wolves if I feel it helps the village. That's what I did there, that's what I'm doing here.

Cliff Notes: I blocked Luckay (i was village roleblocker). Luckay claimed to peek a wolf the night I blocked him. I knew he was lying, but went along with it because:

a) I thought the person he fake-seered as wolf was a great lynch
b) I knew if he was lying he'd get lynched the next day.

Here, I lied about my credits, because if I tell the truth, I'm useless, and might as well be a vanillager.

GetThere1Time · #**3513** 02-01-2007, 04:54 PM

GT1T has still not been talking to Zurvan at night but that means absolutely nothing either way.

Also here's the deal, it's this simple imo. We have 2 Doctors, we've had 3 confirmeds, 2 of whom are dead. There should have been some fear on which one of us to kill and if they should be killing us at all yet over the doctors. This leads me to believe one of the doctors is evil. We can go about this 2 ways:

Way 1: Both come out with lists of who they protected and success rates, we lynch them, we sort out the rest later if neither are evil.

Way 2: Both Doctors protect me every night until the end of the game and if we make it to the final 3(4 I guess), we will have two doctors and a random dude in the end game and a very tough choice.

Maybe I'm nuts but I like way 1 better right now. I'm trying to think of a healthier alternative.

HerbieGRD · #**3514** 02-01-2007, 05:15 PM

I really don't have it in me to argue any more today so after this I am pretty much done. I was in Star Wars with Zurvan and this situation is totally different than that one was. There is no way Zurvan does what he did in this game as a villager because he knows it is too likely that someone like me will call him out for it and use it to get him lynched. In Star Wars there is no way anyone could have found out about his FPS unless he revealed it to get Luckay lynched if Luckay turned out to be a wolf. And on the tiny tiny chance that he would try something like that as a villager he would definitely shoot a PM to his confirmed mason explaining himself the night he posted the phony list.

One more time

Lynch Zurvan

GetThere1Time · #**3515** 02-01-2007, 05:34 PM

Well atleast herb is def a villager albeit a stubborn one.

GetThere1Time · #**3516** 02-01-2007, 05:58 PM

Also see:

[ QUOTE ]

I agree on fcbl, stephen is not a good vote in my opinion but it's too late.
Seer picks should be divided, I sugest Deana takes top half.
One should peek lastchance.

[/ QUOTE ]

This is a Clowntable Day 1 post IMMEDIATELY before night and Stephen gets lynched. I highly doubt a borg says something like this right before another borg is going down.

Conclusion: Clown is likely to be a good guy.

soah · #**3517** 02-01-2007, 06:27 PM

clown -
fcbl - mdd
gt1t - spook
herbie - zurvan
lc -
mdd - spook
spook - clown
zurvan - spook

soah · #**3518** 02-01-2007, 06:38 PM

edit: The following post is being overruled by a forthcoming announcement. Please disregard this one.

*** IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT ***

Night will not fall until tomorrow night at 9:30. This is because at this stage of the game I feel that it is important for everyone to be able to participate every single day, and clowntable cannot post today. Replacing him at this stage is not practical. This decision would be made regardless of his role in the game and should not be construed as meaning anything one way or another.

*** IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT ***

soah · #**3519** 02-01-2007, 06:40 PM

Anonymous question:

Can the Borg transport someone into his own room at night and kill him?

No.

Zurvan · #**3520** 02-01-2007, 06:41 PM

Herbie

My last comment on this (haha):

I'm doing what I think is best as a villager. I'm sorry you can't see that, I'm pretty sure you have blinders on me. Ever since day 1 in Malloreon, you've had a habit of jumping on every second post I make that's incredibly annoying. You claim to know how I play better than GT1T and Durron, who I have probably played at least 15 games with each. This is a unique game, and called for a unique - and unusual for me - strategy.

Frankly, it never occurred to me to PM GT and justify my actions to him. Had we talked, and credits came up, I probably would have mentioned it. But we didn't, so I didn't.