*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread* 2

[Spellmen]

Only start 2 WRs so barring injury I haven't yet considered starting anyone but Holt and Smith on non bye weeks

[ScottieK]

Two trades proposed to me by the same team.

My team's QB's and RB's:
QB - C. Palmer, M. Brunell
RB - E. James, C. Dillon, M. Jones-Drew, L. Washington

His team's QB's and RB's:
QB - Leftwich, P. Rivers
RB - Tomlinson, D. Foster, T. Henry, W. McGahee, D. Williams

Trade A proposal: P. Rivers and W. McGahee for C. Palmer

Trade B proposal: B. Leftwich and T. Henry for C. Palmer

He knows I'm weak at RB (James and Dillon haven't done squat) but is giving up Palmer (who is doing okay, but should deliver more as the season goes on) too much? He'll probably mix and match the QB/RB's he offered, so I could counter. I have KC and ARI's defense and a couple guys I could dump or trade 2 for 1 to someone else to make room on my roster. FWIW my team's ranked last. Thoughts?

ScottieK

[lastchance]

I'd take Rivers and McGahee in an instant, but I'm no expert.

[splashpot]

I'd also take the McGahee deal.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
My lineup is:

Pennington
Leftwich
LJ
Julius Jones
Maroney
Travis Henry
Chester Taylor
Steve Smith
Torry Holt
Branch
Reggie Williams
Winslow
Gould
Vinatieri
SD

Is it worth it to move Smith or Holt and pick up a second big time RB like Portis, Tiki Barber, Rudi Johnson? Those are the only guys right now I think I would move him for

Also apologize in advance for carrying 2 kickers. But I am a PSU grad and had to put up with Robbie Gould, plus he is exactly 1 year older than me so I have a weird fantasy attachment to him

[/ QUOTE ]

Dude your team is pretty stacked. I could concieve of trading Smith for someone like portis, or maybe packaging smith and jones for a guy like portis and a decent 2nd or 3rd WR. But really I dont think you should be in a rush to move anyone.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
Now one of mine. 10 team league. 1QB/2RB/3WR/1TE/1K/1D My team:
QB- Hasselbeck, Rivers
RB- LT, Dunn, Edge, M Barber, Mo Morris
WR- Chambers, Glenn, Ward, Williamson
TE- Heap, Winslow
K- Akers
D- Pitt

Since I don't really need 2 TEs, I thought it might be worth it to trade Heap (he has a bye this week) for a good WR. I'm just not sure what calibur WR I could get for Heap. Here are the 3 teams that are hurting most at TE. Possible targets in <font color="red">red</font>.

Team 1:
QB- Bledsoe, Warner
RB- Tiki, McGahee, Parker, Lewis
WR- <font color="red"> Driver, Berrian</font>, Rod Smith, Reggie Williams, Cotchery
TE- Witten
K- Vanderjagt, Longwell
D- Dallas

Team 2:
QB- Eli, Vick
RB- Jackson, Maroney, Dillon, Benson
WR- TO, <font color="red">Housh, Coles, Antonio Bryant</font>
TE- Cooley, Colston (who I hope will consider playing as a WR)
K- Kaeding
D- TB, NE

Team 3:
QB- Carr, McNair
RB- Rudi, Alexander, Chester Taylor, Bush
WR- <font color="red">Andre Johnson, Edwards, Fitzgerald</font>, Stallworth, Branch, Baskett
TE- Heath Miller
K- Feely
D- Bal

Heap is the #1 TE in the league thus far so I should be able to get a good WR. Considering who I deserve for Heap, my opponent's need, and what you think will be accepted, who do you think is my best bet?

[/ QUOTE ]

Team three is by far the deepest at reciever so I would target him.

Try to get johnson if you can for heap otherwise maybe offer winslow for fits branch or edwards.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
Two trades proposed to me by the same team.

My team's QB's and RB's:
QB - C. Palmer, M. Brunell
RB - E. James, C. Dillon, M. Jones-Drew, L. Washington

His team's QB's and RB's:
QB - Leftwich, P. Rivers
RB - Tomlinson, D. Foster, T. Henry, W. McGahee, D. Williams

Trade A proposal: P. Rivers and W. McGahee for C. Palmer

Trade B proposal: B. Leftwich and T. Henry for C. Palmer

He knows I'm weak at RB (James and Dillon haven't done squat) but is giving up Palmer (who is doing okay, but should deliver more as the season goes on) too much? He'll probably mix and match the QB/RB's he offered, so I could counter. I have KC and ARI's defense and a couple guys I could dump or trade 2 for 1 to someone else to make room on my roster. FWIW my team's ranked last. Thoughts?

ScottieK

[/ QUOTE ]

I like rivers a lot and he only looks like hes getting better.

I would accept his first offer.

[MEbenhoe]

[ QUOTE ]


Trade A proposal: P. Rivers and W. McGahee for C. Palmer


[/ QUOTE ]

How have you not accepted this already?

[ScottieK]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


Trade A proposal: P. Rivers and W. McGahee for C. Palmer


[/ QUOTE ]

How have you not accepted this already?

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm trade-averse...but the way my team is sucking ass right now, nowhere to go but up. Thanks for the advice [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

ScottieK

[Burdzthewurd]

10-team Yahoo League

1 point per reception, 1 point per 10 yards receiving, 20 yards for passing, start 3 WR's and a W/R spot

My QB's:
Rivers
Delhomme
Favre

His QB's:
Brees
Manning

My WR's:
Jennings
Galloway
S. Moss
Cotchery

His WR's:
Chambers
A. Johnson
Mason
Glenn

My TE's:
Colston (also WR)
LJ Smith

He sent me an offer with Brees for Colston, which is a no-brainer rejection with Rivers getting hot. Would counteroffering for Andre Johnson be pretty bad? Thing is all my WR's sans Jennings and one week from Moss have been letdowns, so I've usually started Colston and Smith. My RB's are fine, so don't believe I need anyone else (Parker, Brown, Portis).