Survivor China OFFICIAL THREAD

[Soncy]

Oh where to start. This 'terrible twist' has certainly generated a lot of posts. I'm not happy about Grave Digger being in danger, but I AM very interested in seeing PG and Jaime pay for their actions. Seems like that's what these reality shows boil down to so often...I'm left rooting against people instead of FOR them because the ones I liked got speared. I don't think its time to panic yet on that front. I like Frosti and I like Erik so I'll hold out a little hope for a while.

PG and Jaime may actually have done JRB a big favor. It's weird. I think he's a hole, yet I can't help but feel badly for him when people rip on him for fairly benign comments and actions. However, someone should have warned him before he went on the show that rule number one in basic Survivor strategy is "Don't tell anyone to do anything." Even if it needs to be done and is in the person's best interests as well as the tribe's. Don't say it. People, especially the lazy ones, get all bent out of shape when you order them around. They are likely to rant about how they are an adult and don't need you telling them what to do. Take Sherea for instance: says, "I can cook." Then, when JRB suggests that she do so, she flies off the handle about it. And it wasn't like he was sitting around dictating orders and not doing anything himself. He started some rice and was going to go get some fish and shrimp. Perhaps he can be faulted for approaching people about getting up to do things while they are still in bed, but...{shrug}. Anyway, I'm not sure how the vote goes if his tribe goes to council, so maybe he got a repreive.

Something that really bugs me about Survivor...why in Heaven don't the strong ever band together? Don't they realize that they are each other's only protection? If they don't get together, they garauntee that they will eventually get picked off by the snakey people that are too weak or uncoordinated to win a challenge. Just once, I would like to see the strong competitors band together and be bold enough to go every man for himself against the other strong competitors. Instead it is common to see #2 strategizing with others that #1 needs to go home, when its clear that once #1 is gone, #2 becomes the primary target. {sigh}

To the person who was pipe dreaming about James negotiating with his tribe and playing both sides. I'd be very surprised if that happened. There was a reason they kept him and sent Aaron home. Grave Digger wouldn't be caught dead voting for Aaron so he didn't make any of his tribe members upset. Huge physical threats with poor diplomacy skills just do not make it much past the merge in Survivor.

{sigh} I just hate it when people throw challenges. I always want to see that punished. More so this time because they were so smug about it.

[helloimcdog]

Don't know if this was discussed already, but why was Sherea picked as a strongest player? Erik and Frosti seemed like the obvious choice to me especially knowing the other tribe would take James and Aaron.

Did they explain their choice in the episode?

[scratchy1]

I thought for sure after the immunity challenge they were going to tell them they could not vote off any of the kidnapped tribe members.

[KLJ]

that would have been a great idea.

throwing the challenge is whatever. acting like idiots about it is a whole different story. if james gets eliminated based on anything other than merit next episode, i'm retiring from watching survivor

[pokergrader]

Look I like James as much as anybody but he is playing completely on the level. That isn't really rewarded in survivor.

[EnigmaCanada]

With PG and Jaime: I don't think they should be getting hate from fans for throwing the challenge, because given the twist in the episode, that was the correct strategic move, whether you like it or not.

I do agree that they acted very childish with all the giggling, like they were 6th graders picking on someone.

[cpitt398]

[ QUOTE ]
Don't know if this was discussed already, but why was Sherea picked as a strongest player? Erik and Frosti seemed like the obvious choice to me especially knowing the other tribe would take James and Aaron.

Did they explain their choice in the episode?

[/ QUOTE ]

the only time that tribe lost was when they had guy vs guy and girl vs girl challenges

they needed a strong girl for those type of events

[cpitt398]

i look forward to seeing how James acts next week. If I was him I would eat every bit of food they had.

[EnigmaCanada]

[ QUOTE ]
i look forward to seeing how James acts next week. If I was him I would eat every bit of food they had.

[/ QUOTE ]

James needs to communicate to his original tribe what took place, and get them to try to throw the next challenge also. The problem is that James will have to compete against Frosti and Sherea in the next challenge, if all other competitors give no effort.

[roy_miami]

That was a sick [censored] twist. I don't blame Jamie and PG for throwing it as much as the producers for not thinking it through. When the producers realized what was happening they should have thrown a monkey wrench in their plan and kicked somebody off at random (and secretly made sure PG was the "random" one).

Next week James should quit the game before the challenge. Does anybody remember if they still vote somebody off when a member quits? I'm pretty sure its happened at least once before but I don't remember how it played out.