Old-Timers Game (GAME THREAD)

[Nicholasp27]

i'm not sure why u are so clear; at least eskimo has the tokyo kill going for him as evidence; ur clearing is just based on postings

if u are villager, then chuck is the wolf 99% of the time, as eskimo is only a wolf here 1% of the time

[mostsmooth]

[ QUOTE ]
holy crap reading back.... this is the sickest wolf game ever played by anyone ever if its vr, if she is the wolf here im actually scared to play with her again....

has to be chuck..... still re-reading for anything solid

[/ QUOTE ]
nich, this eskimo post makes me think hes the wolf really, or at least the most wolflike of the 3 remaining, but only slightly.
one reason is because im not under the impression anybody has done any super wolfing. when we find out the last wolf, im not going to be surprised at all, no matter who it is.
eskimo really sounds like hes trying to setup a “OMG I CANT BELIEVE IT WAS VR THE WHOLE TIME” speech tomorrow if we go chuck and are wrong.
eskimo has the Tokyo kill on his side, but im not sure how much that clears him, plus I want to revisit that day and see how many peeks Tokyo laid out, if eskimo was somebody he cleared that day, etc.
chuck has only the jared vote on his side, which is not much either considering that’s one of the things vr is apparently being cleared for as well. chuck did have that apparent (faked?) anger about the seer strategy posts, which really struck me as odd.
vr has her jared vote, and a couple of those other things she listed on her side, but imo none were really things a wolf couldn’t do. vr did say on the same day within a few hours that chuck/yuppie haven’t done anything to be villagers, then said chuck was her number 1 villager (or was it #2? either way its odd)
im still gonna read for a bit today when I get time
if it takes too long, ill just vote

[Nicholasp27]

yeah, i'll read the thread again looking for clues today

but i think i wanna go chuck->vr->eskimo at this point

[Nicholasp27]

eskimo defense summed up:

a) tokyo came out d2 with 2 villagers; not very buyable for the wolves (tho i tried to help there)
b) d3, he had another villager, but traz came out with 3 accurate villagers, so they killed him
c) d4, he came out with boiler as wolf and they killed him


i think it's very likely they didn't kill him if he's accurate d2 because

a) they don't believe he'd come out that early
b) killing him confirms esk/shorty

i think they don't kill him the next day because traz came out with 3 villagers accurately

i think they kill him the next night only if eskimo is villager


think about it; if they wanted to set up eskimo for the win, why not just do it d2; if esk is a wolf, they kill tokyo d2 and esk is cleared

[Nicholasp27]

also, 'clearing' eskimo earlier makes it less likely seers ever peek eskimo; if they kill tokyo n2, seers hardly ever peek eskimo/shorty

if they wait until n4, better shot that esk gets peeked


so best chance to setup eskimo is n2, especially when they had no better leads (amp?) anyway; while later on they may have better seer chances

[mostsmooth]

[ QUOTE ]
also, 'clearing' eskimo earlier makes it less likely seers ever peek eskimo; if they kill tokyo n2, seers hardly ever peek eskimo/shorty

if they wait until n4, better shot that esk gets peeked


so best chance to setup eskimo is n2, especially when they had no better leads (amp?) anyway; while later on they may have better seer chances

[/ QUOTE ]
i agree with what youre saying nich

im still gonna look though

[ QUOTE ]
CONCRETE PROOF:

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
vr - if you are villager as i suspect you are rite now dont stress we win.....

remember that i thought it was spook/chuck the whole time

[/ QUOTE ]
So because you have been suspecting me the whole time that makes you more likely to be village?? Another WTF??

[/ QUOTE ]


[/ QUOTE ]
nich, what do you think about the above?

[Nicholasp27]

who said which parts of that quote?

[mostsmooth]

[ QUOTE ]
who said which parts of that quote?

[/ QUOTE ]

eskimo said vr....

chuck replied with so...

[VoraciousReader]

Think about the wolf team.

By the night tokyo dies they are in desperate straits. We've killed 3 wolves in 4 days: jaredl, hbe, and boiler.

Do you think eskimo is clever enough and fps-y enough to gamble on kill and clear himself?

Because I do.

And if he is the last wolf, that will be the play that decided the game.

On the other hand, I am a popular seer peek and I already had a claimed seer "wolf" peek me. Do you folks REALLY believe my strategy for winning this game was to completely run through the rest of my wolf team and kill them off one by one?

Seriously?

[Nicholasp27]

no, i don't; that's why chuck is the final wolf