Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[Chuck Norris]

[ QUOTE ]
I'm amused and astonished that Mark's examination of the mets /herbie combination seemed to miss the most obvious explanation - they're both villagers. Actually, it kinda missed the explanation that METS was a villager.

Makes me wonder.

4 of the 7 evils:

VR
jgunnip
Mark
Mets

Your welcome.

[/ QUOTE ]
so youre saying the most obvious explanation is mets is villager, and that makes mets a villager? (i dont yet know what the explanation was for of course). or are you saying that mark was trying to score some street cred and therfore mets and mark are wolves? if so, then why isnt herbie a wolf as well?
ok , gonna go eat

[DustinG]

[ QUOTE ]
so you think we should vote for him?

[/ QUOTE ]

no- he said its not important atm and that he'd address it closer to night, so vote for who you think is a wolf

also scott, [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img]

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I'm amused and astonished that Mark's examination of the mets /herbie combination seemed to miss the most obvious explanation - they're both villagers. Actually, it kinda missed the explanation that METS was a villager.

Makes me wonder.

4 of the 7 evils:

VR
jgunnip
Mark
Mets

Your welcome.

[/ QUOTE ]
so youre saying the most obvious explanation is mets is villager, and that makes mets a villager? (i dont yet know what the explanation was for of course). or are you saying that mark was trying to score some street cred and therfore mets and mark are wolves? if so, then why isnt herbie a wolf as well?
ok , gonna go eat

[/ QUOTE ]

The "most obvious" because mets is a villager (OK, not a wolf) more often than not, based on pure probability.

Mark analysed the situation from all angles re: Herbie's role, but only one re: mets's... he just acted as if Mets was a wolf, without saying it.

Therefore, I conclude, that Mark is a wolf, with mets, and was trying to put suspicion on Herbie (who's a villager, ldo) based on his interactions with Mets, that he framed as suspicious. He just missed the fact that he implicitly called mets a wolf in his pot.

[KyrosMother]

[ QUOTE ]
so you think we should vote for him?

[/ QUOTE ]

Wow.

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]
so you think we should vote for him?

[/ QUOTE ]

1 post, and you're trying to follow a villagers lead on who to vote for

Hot

We found number 5

This game is getting easy.

btw, if this dude is a wolf ( he is ), then Norris & whoever he was talking about are villagers

[antidan444]

I don't know about the dustin read, but what scott just said about mets makes me think they're both villagers.

[Zurvan]

[ QUOTE ]

btw, if this dude is a wolf ( he is ), then Norris & whoever he was talking about are villagers

[/ QUOTE ]

OK, scotty was talking about dustin

if tarheel is a wolf, scotty & dustin are villagers. Book it

[tarheeljks]

hah if i were a wolf i would not do something this dumb. it was an honest question

[Epicurus]

[ QUOTE ]
I'm amused and astonished that Mark's examination of the mets /herbie combination seemed to miss the most obvious explanation - they're both villagers...

[/ QUOTE ]

Good.
[ QUOTE ]

Makes me wonder.

4 of the 7 evils:

VR
jgunnip
Mark
Mets

Your welcome.

[/ QUOTE ]

Not so good.

[DustinG]

using Dmk's response to clear Mets is just plain wrong and also potentially very dangerous

I do think Mets is a villager, but lets leave Dmk's post out of it please

when I modded BobO's game I basically called OH a dumbass in the thread, which I probably shouldn't have a done (he did ask me a ridiculous question though) and he was a wolf.