Why are most offensive lineman white and defensive lineman black?

[goodsamaritan]

They are very similar positions, yet the racial barrier between the two positions is almost never crossed. Do you think there are actually genetic differences that make whites better O lineman and blacks better D lineman, or do you think stereotypes cause coaches to slot players into one side or the other based on race? I'd like to see Real Sports do a segment on this.

[Needle77]

[ QUOTE ]

They are very similar positions

[/ QUOTE ]

I stopped reading there, no they are two completely different positions. I'm pretty sure Dwight Freeney would struggle immensely with blocking Simeon Rice.

[goodsamaritan]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

They are very similar positions

[/ QUOTE ]

I stopped reading there, no they are two completely different positions. I'm pretty sure Dwight Freeney would struggle immensely with blocking Simeon Rice.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well you don't have to agree with that assessment to answer the question. Explain to me if/how the differences in the positions make one race better suited to one position or the other.

[Jack of Arcades]

Are most offensive lineman white?

[Jack of Arcades]

I mean when you think of the top young left tackles, only one of them is white (Joe Thomas). Well, Jake Long, too. But you have D'Brickishaw, Marcus McNeil, Jammal Brown, etc. The dominant LTs in the past years have been black: Willie Roaf, Walter Jones, Orlando Pace, Bryant McKinnie.

[pudley4]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

They are very similar positions

[/ QUOTE ]

I stopped reading there, no they are two completely different positions. I'm pretty sure Dwight Freeney would struggle immensely with blocking Simeon Rice.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well you don't have to agree with that assessment to answer the question. Explain to me if/how the differences in the positions make one race better suited to one position or the other.

[/ QUOTE ]

OL is all about knowing assignments - aka 'smarts'. You have to be able to recognize and remember lots of different schemes.
DL is all about speed and strength - aka 'physical traits'. Just go make a play.

Once you realize that, you'll see the obvious answer to your question. Looking further, we see what happens when a really smart big black guy plays OL (Larry Allen, Orlando Pace, Walter Jones, Randall McDaniel, etc)

[NT!]

[ QUOTE ]


OL is all about knowing assignments - aka 'smarts'. You have to be able to recognize and remember lots of different schemes.
DL is all about speed and strength - aka 'physical traits'. Just go make a play.

Once you realize that, you'll see the obvious answer to your question. Looking further, we see what happens when a really smart big black guy plays OL (Larry Allen, Orlando Pace, Walter Jones, Randall McDaniel, etc)

[/ QUOTE ]

so basically, black people are big and strong, but too dumb to play OL? except a few outliers?

nice post

[Pudge714]

I think the premise of the OP is flawed. I think the only positions this is really true for is centre and that's obviously because white people are smarter.

<font color="white">It's a joke please don't ban me </font>

[Dudd]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


OL is all about knowing assignments - aka 'smarts'. You have to be able to recognize and remember lots of different schemes.
DL is all about speed and strength - aka 'physical traits'. Just go make a play.

Once you realize that, you'll see the obvious answer to your question. Looking further, we see what happens when a really smart big black guy plays OL (Larry Allen, Orlando Pace, Walter Jones, Randall McDaniel, etc)

[/ QUOTE ]

so basically, black people are big and strong, but too dumb to play OL? except a few outliers?

nice post

[/ QUOTE ]

Or that a position that requires technique more than elite athleticism is more likely to draw from the ~75% of Americans that are white than position that require elite athleticism, which black players are more likely to have.

[34TheTruth34]

[ QUOTE ]
OL is all about knowing assignments - aka 'smarts'. You have to be able to recognize and remember lots of different schemes.
DL is all about speed and strength - aka 'physical traits'. Just go make a play.

Once you realize that, you'll see the obvious answer to your question.

[/ QUOTE ]

umm...wow