***yankees official offseason thread*****

[Sickboy]

[ QUOTE ]
Oh ya and I've been meaning to mention:

There was a BP article a while back saying that the yankees should trade melky and cano + other stuff I don't remember for Cabrera

I jus wanted to let you sound like an illogical ass first, didn't take long

[/ QUOTE ]

then BP are idiots.

We'd have to give up Melky + Cano + Kennedy + Horne or Sanchez or Tabata to match what others are going to offer for Miguel.

If BP is saying we should give up all of that for Miguel then they are retardo. We shoulda just offered Arod 300 million instead and kept all those prospects

[onlinebeginner]

The mistake of AROD not being resigned should be viewed as a sunk cost...

that should have no effect on the MIGGY trade besides that we now need a 3B

you continue to be illogical and arrogant but you do seem knowledgable, more so than myself

Give me some floors and ceiling comparisons for Horne Sanchez and Tabata... unless they're guaranteed studs, this trade makes sense for the yanks

[Sickboy]

[ QUOTE ]
The mistake of AROD not being resigned should be viewed as a sunk cost...

that should have no effect on the MIGGY trade besides that we now need a 3B

you continue to be illogical and arrogant but you do seem knowledgable, more so than myself

Give me some floors and ceiling comparisons for Horne Sanchez and Tabata... unless they're guaranteed studs, this trade makes sense for the yanks

[/ QUOTE ]

Its basically this..we trade for Cabrera and give up X+X+X+X+X...we now need a 2nd baseman, a #4 starter, if Andy retires a #3 and #2 starter. a CF. and an entire bullpen + we need to resign our closer and catcher + the disaster that is 1st base. And in a year or two we may need a new 3rd basemen because Miguel has to be moved to 1st base.

OR

We can trade much much less for LaRoche or Tejada.

Not to mention...we NEED [censored] PITCHING!!

[kyleb]

cano is not easily replaceable are you nuts. he is a 10 WARP3 player at second base and is arb-eligible.

[Rubeskies]

[ QUOTE ]
cano is not easily replaceable are you nuts. he is a 10 WARP3 player at second base and is arb-eligible.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes, please explain why Cano is replaceable whoever said that. Especially considering that he is still young and may eventually develop 30 HR power.

[Triumph36]

trading cano for cabrera in any deal is beyond stupid

god onlinebeginner just get over your irrational hate for melky and irrational love for the soon to be broken down aaron rowand

[Sickboy]

its LaRoche or Tejada tradewise...otherwise well end up with some FA scrub or maybe Crede

[g-bebe]

Cano... must... STAY!

<-------------

[MikeyPatriot]

[ QUOTE ]
its LaRoche or Tejada tradewise...otherwise well end up with some FA scrub or maybe Crede

[/ QUOTE ]

Please?

[sublime]

[ QUOTE ]
Cano... must... STAY!

<-------------

[/ QUOTE ]

hes the most valuable guy on the roster. mcab is obv tempting, and they are close in overall value, but cano just blows the thing out the water by being so much cheaper.