Star Trek: The Next Generation 3 [GAME THREAD]

[clowntable]

[ QUOTE ]
Clown is Borg if Luckay is villager. He is already moving on to who should be lynched based on the role he knows Luckay has. Whether that means we shouldn't lynch Luckay is a step I am not willing to take.

Clown's post reminds me of Dustin 'knowing' Jack Bando was the real seer, when all the evidence was to the contrary.

[/ QUOTE ]
Specifically I'd normaly respond to this along the lines of "dude you're using the same logic for which you think I'm wolfy (if luckay is village i'm wolf)"

[durron597]

[ QUOTE ]

durron "DAMMIT GUYS VOTE LUCKAY"

asplain please.

also vote Clowntable

(posting from work and can't post from here any more - will be back in ~6 hours or so)

[/ QUOTE ]

i genuinely thought he was Q; i couldn't think of a motive for him to make that claim as a villager

[durron597]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Clown is Borg if Luckay is villager. He is already moving on to who should be lynched based on the role he knows Luckay has. Whether that means we shouldn't lynch Luckay is a step I am not willing to take.

Clown's post reminds me of Dustin 'knowing' Jack Bando was the real seer, when all the evidence was to the contrary.

[/ QUOTE ]
Specifically I'd normaly respond to this along the lines of "dude you're using the same logic for which you think I'm wolfy (if luckay is village i'm wolf)"

[/ QUOTE ]

wdcbooks used this same logic in two towers for how he handled fmxda, and he was a wolf.

i love my vote

[durron597]

[ QUOTE ]
durron

[/ QUOTE ]

what are you smoking this game? can i have some?

[FCBLComish]

[ QUOTE ]
Books made a very strange post along the lines of "TFG left me a plain old villager role".
This rang alarm bells with me that he was indeed a doctor/seer so I just tried to not make him post too much. I'm sure that's why he was killed.

[/ QUOTE ]


Sure= wolf

Clowntable

[durron597]

[ QUOTE ]
OK,

Lets assume a couple of things for a moment.

Who does everyone think the clearest villagers are for the most part?

durron/lastchance?

Why was books killed last night instead?

[/ QUOTE ]

let me guess,

after you get me lynched and i turn up villager you're going to try to get lastchance lynched next?

[clowntable]

I'm smoking a healthy dose of "let's not lynch villagers".
Apparantly you didn't get your fix yesterday.

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
OK,

Lets assume a couple of things for a moment.

Who does everyone think the clearest villagers are for the most part?

durron/lastchance?

Why was books killed last night instead?

[/ QUOTE ]
I wouldn't have killed Durron or Lastchance last night because the same thing that makes them obvious villagers to me also makes it highly unlikely that they are power roles. The wolves need to kill seers, doctors, and worf more than they need to kill obvious villagers early. Books was giving off power role vibes yesterday big time but I didn't get the sense he was evil so I laid off pushing him.

There is also the possibility that Books was right about something important that is not common knowledge and the wolves were afraid he would convince people so they killed him.

It seems pretty clear to me that the wolves are being led by someone who is a very good wolf given how splintered village opinion is at this point - often when village opinion is very splintered early you have a group of very good wolves

There is also the remote possibility that the wolves discovered his role on n1

All things considered I think I like a Clowntable vote today

Other people who could be wolves
Nez
DMK
Neil S

[Skoob]

[ QUOTE ]
I don't think the "villager tell" Skoob gave last night is as accurate as some of you people seem to think it is (remember FCBL in Mallorean 2) but after reading the turbo where he was a wolf last night there is absolutely no way he is a wolf in this game.

[/ QUOTE ]
Are you slamming my skillz? Re-read that turbo. I gots MAD skillz.

Why aren't more people voting for DMK?

[HerbieGRD]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I don't think the "villager tell" Skoob gave last night is as accurate as some of you people seem to think it is (remember FCBL in Mallorean 2) but after reading the turbo where he was a wolf last night there is absolutely no way he is a wolf in this game.

[/ QUOTE ]
Are you slamming my skillz? Re-read that turbo. I gots MAD skillz.

Why aren't more people voting for DMK?

[/ QUOTE ]
Not slamming you at all - just saying that your game here is absolutely nothing like your game in that turbo - ergo you are not a wolf