Average Speed XVII Game Thread - Page 313

clowntable · #**3121** 08-10-2007, 09:00 AM

I'm kinda sorry for how traz's game influenced my play in this one.
Did anyone mention scott's novote when it was a flip between me and fish? He was around and posted. After fish comes back wolf that is pretty incriminating.
Also, why did dustin live this long? Because scott was making a case against him and thought maybe he could get lynched.
Anyhow, easy to say from the outside.

Thx for modding smell godd job (except for the coinflip :P)

p.s.: I agree that the situation after the seers died was actually good for the village.

durron597 · #**3122** 08-10-2007, 09:03 AM

[ QUOTE ]
Great job on pulling through Scott and Fish. People don't give Scott enough credit as a wolf. He's actually a very smart wolf which kind of surprised me.

[/ QUOTE ]

scotthoward isn't an idiot, he just plays one on TV

DustinG · #**3123** 08-10-2007, 09:10 AM

[ QUOTE ]

Did anyone mention scott's novote when it was a flip between me and fish? He was around and posted. After fish comes back wolf that is pretty incriminating.

[/ QUOTE ]

its kinda disgusting that Supine's "I abstain" was used to incriminate him when that was actually really villagery given the situation- a newbie wolf is going to actually say "I abstain" while leaving his partner up to a flip!?!?! (and yes, I mentioned this), while Scott not voting wasnt mentioned at all.

I take the blame for losing this game (and not for lynching any of the people Shorty said not to lynch)- but for not defending Supine harder when the game should have been a lock.

Nicholasp27 · #**3124** 08-10-2007, 09:12 AM

so, was luckay or nez the n0 peek?

Neil S · #**3125** 08-10-2007, 09:13 AM

[ QUOTE ]
so, was luckay or nez the n0 peek?

[/ QUOTE ]I really shouldn't have to answer this. I agree with Scott: If my peek wasn't the one in which I said "I'm the Seer!" then I should be banned from POG, heh.

Neil S · #**3126** 08-10-2007, 09:15 AM

I cleared Nez because I knew Luckay was a wolf, and Luckay fake seer hinted with Nez as village. I just see virtually no chance at all that Luckay fake peeks incorrectly d1 like that, because if Nez gets peeked and lynched (perfectly plausible given how often Nez seems to get to endgame) then that destroys his ability to fake seer.

Nicholasp27 · #**3127** 08-10-2007, 09:19 AM

well i don't agree with using the words "when i die" with "don't ever lynch player x" if u are the seer, unless that is ur peek

but oh well

DustinG · #**3128** 08-10-2007, 09:26 AM

Neil,

you basically chose to come out as seer D1. Given that you had a wolf and there was no guarantee that you'll get another peek (given the no n1 peek)- maybe thats smart, idk

but maybe you dont leave a hint and gamble that you can live until D3- thoughts on this?

DustinG · #**3129** 08-10-2007, 09:27 AM

[ QUOTE ]
well i don't agree with using the words "when i die" with "don't ever lynch player x" if u are the seer, unless that is ur peek

but oh well

[/ QUOTE ]

if you read all of Neil's posts, he made it pretty clear Luckay was the peek.

Neil S · #**3130** 08-10-2007, 09:29 AM

[ QUOTE ]
Neil,

you basically chose to come out as seer D1. Given that you had a wolf and there was no guarantee that you'll get another peek (given the no n1 peek)- maybe thats smart, idk

but maybe you dont leave a hint and gamble that you can live until D3- thoughts on this?

[/ QUOTE ]I thought Shortline was getting me lynched, and I thought he was a wolf, so once he said I needed to die I figured I wasn't getting another peek at all.

But honestly, I don't know at all what to do with an n0 wolf in a long game.