LionelHutz00

[daryn]

diablo i'm in agreement with you near 100%. it's not like, oops i messed up. the guy knows exactly what he did, and knew what he was doing when he did it.

[MrWookie]

El D,

You make a compelling case. My mind had clearly suppressed the memories of having stupidly clicked on that link (why?! why?!) so thoroughly that I was thinking abstractly in terms of "good poster posts something really, really stupid" rather than the specific case of "good poster posts horse porn."

[Leader]

If the guy isn't going to do it again (and it appears he won't), permabanning him is a mistake. It's in the best interest of 2+2 for him to come back and be a quality contributer. Sure he could make another account, but maybe he doesn't or doesn't post as much. What did 2+2 gain then in return for losing a good poster? Deterrent value? If so, why not just make an example of the first crappy poster to do it?

[El Diablo]

Leader,

So, ER doctors and cancer researchers should get free rein to rob a certain number of banks and not be put in jail?

[El Diablo]

All,

I'm really surprised at the level of opposition we have here to the simple idea that if someone posts inline bestiality pics their account should be nuked.

[JaredL]

Diablito,

The only explanation I can give is that a fairly high number of mods think a user should never permabanned for a single post if it isn't spam.

I personally can imagine several reasons for people to be banned for one post and horse porn is well over that line.

[Dids]

Maybe it's just that years of the internet have totally left me numb to anything shocking, but I'm not sure I find inline beastiality any worse than incline normal porn, or inline scat porn or whatever.

I think given current standards, having that be a "one and done" offense doesn't track with how we've handled stuff like this in the past. I think if we want to change that, the bar should be lower on the offensive meter than horse porn.

[nation]

haha wtf dids...i've seen all sorts of weird porn but bestiality is not even comparable to normal porn. i'm pretty sure we agree on that but i think it's FAAAAAR worse that inline normal porn.

[El Diablo]

Dibs,

OK, lemme go out on a limb really far here and make this bold statement too: If someone posts inline scat porn pics their account should be nuked.

[Leader]

[ QUOTE ]
Leader,

So, ER doctors and cancer researchers should get free rein to rob a certain number of banks and not be put in jail?

[/ QUOTE ]

So they should get life sentences and be treated the same as life long criminals?