Settle this Baseball Argument

[MEbenhoe]

It is the bottom of the 9th in a tie game. You have men on 1st and 2nd with no outs and your 2,3,4 hitters coming up to bat. The man on 2nd has slightly above average to above average speed. Your 2,3,4 hitters are your best 3 hitters, can all hit for power and all have solid BA/OBP numbers, and are all significantly better hitters than the #5 hitter. What do you call for with the #2 hitter coming up to bat?

Please answer the poll question and explain your answer in thread.