The Revolution - Game Thread - Page 121

HerbieGRD · #**1201** 11-27-2007, 06:55 PM

Today's official "last count before I get home from work" count, but the next count should be significantly earlier than it was yesterday.

[0] Bulletproof Monk voted for NicholasP27
[0] Chim17
[0] DMK voted for NicholasP27
[0] drzen
[0] Epicurus voted for NicholasP27
[0] FCBLComish voted for Reno expat
[0] FMXDA voted for WDCBooks
[0] GetThere1Time voted for WDCBooks
[0] JennFox voted for NicholasP27
[0] jgunnip voted for NicholasP27
[0] Kokiri voted for NicholasP27
[0] Kristiefix voted for VoraciousReader
[0] Kyro
[1] Lastchance
[0] LuckayLuck voted for WDCBooks
[0] MDoranD voted for NicholasP27
[0] Metsandfinsfan voted for Lastchance
 [11] NicholasP27 voted for WDCBooks 
[0] OurHouse voted for WDCBooks
[1] Reno expat voted for NicholasP27
[0] Resnick voted for NicholasP27
[0] Solanthos voted for NicholasP27
[0] tarheeljks
[1] VoraciousReader voted for WDCBooks
[6] WDCBooks voted for NicholasP27

9:00 good, 9:01 no good

JennFox · #**1202** 11-27-2007, 06:57 PM

[ QUOTE ]
ok so its lynch books or lynch nich.

I'm gonna make an assumption that Books wouldn't claim to be able to avoid day lynch if he actually couldn't. It wouldnt make any sense especially on the block. Lets break it on down.

Lynch Books with Nich as second bandwagon

If Books is good the lynch rolls off of him and evil Nich dies. If Books is evil the lynch rolls off of him and vanillage Nich dies (based on the fact he hasnt claimed.) This has the added bonus of removing any day lynch evasion from him if he's evil and if he's good it'll be proven and we wont be lynching him anyway

We lynch Nich

If Books is good, Nich dies, Books is confirmed and he retains a useless day lynch evasion power. If Books is evil, we lynch vanillage Nich and then have to take 2 more days to kill Books.

I'm failing to see how lynching Nich would ever be better than lynching Books with Nich as a secondary wagon here.

[/ QUOTE ]

um... he wont retain his "useless" lynch evasion power. he would be nightkilled, bc from what i understand, he has more powers?

lastchance · #**1203** 11-27-2007, 06:57 PM

Gt1t, the thing is, apparently books is claiming point powers. Obviously, this could be entirely BS, but if it is true, obviously, books could save his points and use his POINTS to do something else which might be more useful.

kristiefix · #**1204** 11-27-2007, 06:57 PM

[ QUOTE ]
question for dmk, luckay, bggers
do bgg seers normally not leave any hints on day 1?

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes. Although, I still think the paranoid comment is more of a hint then anything. LC could have been the view though because she doesn't play with him enough to rely on a read I would think. Tough call, definitely.

Day 1 hints are tough. She may have thought she would be safe longer because she is new? That isn't completely unreasonable.

Bulletproof Monk · #**1205** 11-27-2007, 06:58 PM

books

books - how many points do you have to spread across powers? im assuming this is exactly the same as macguyver from mish mash?

JennFox · #**1206** 11-27-2007, 06:59 PM

yes, lets break down all the village powers we possibly can, this early in the game. lets never ever gamble, and lets certainly second guess ourselves every step of the way and make bad last second decisions because of it...

i thought you were smart, gt1t..

kristiefix · #**1207** 11-27-2007, 07:04 PM

[ QUOTE ]
Kristiefix - Plenty of response to conversation re: flirting. Randomly pops back in later for the same reason. Makes a vote at the end of the day. And while this solely doesnt make her evil, it's the only thing she's posted and there's a good bit of it. If you're around to respond to this crap, then you're around to give input, which didnt happen. Neutral at best imo.

[/ QUOTE ]

I don't always add quality discussion, I'll give you that. Mostly it depends on my mood. Also, I am not around during the day because I cannot access 2+2... I am on now though... what do you want to know?

Bulletproof Monk · #**1208** 11-27-2007, 07:08 PM

[ QUOTE ]
well, assuming for ease of argument that you're good, that must make P thru T a significant favourite, since that includes the letter R.

[/ QUOTE ]

JUST HAD TO POINT OUT THIS IS THE BEST POST OF THE THREAD THUS FAR

lastchance · #**1209** 11-27-2007, 07:10 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
well, assuming for ease of argument that you're good, that must make P thru T a significant favourite, since that includes the letter R.

[/ QUOTE ]

JUST HAD TO POINT OUT THIS IS THE BEST POST OF THE THREAD THUS FAR

[/ QUOTE ]
Also by far the stupidest.

Bulletproof Monk · #**1210** 11-27-2007, 07:11 PM

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
well, assuming for ease of argument that you're good, that must make P thru T a significant favourite, since that includes the letter R.

[/ QUOTE ]

JUST HAD TO POINT OUT THIS IS THE BEST POST OF THE THREAD THUS FAR

[/ QUOTE ]
Also by far the stupidest.

[/ QUOTE ]

im still lolling and thinking about sesame street tbh