Need help picking a college roommate (long)

[an0nym0u5]

Roommate possibility #1:
+Will pay $800/month
+Will be leasing from June 1 - Jan 31 (8 month lease)
+Should be graduating after Fall semester
+Small chance he may renew lease and stay for Spring semester (until end of May)
+Says he would find me a roommate for Spring semester (but he has some weird friends)
+Has lots of money
-Has extreme case of ADD
-Sometimes gets on my nerves
-His room is always messy
-His current roommates tell me he never cleans
-Like him less than Roommate possibility #2

Rooommate possibility #2:
+Will pay $725/month
+Will be leasing from End of August - End of May (9 month lease)
+Possibility he may renew lease and stay during Summer 08
+Good friend of 5 years; Get along great
+His GF is the president of a female organization (will have lots of females over!)
-Tight on money, but will still pay the rent/bills

If I go with Roommate #1, I'll have a roommate for Summer/Fall/Winter, but then I'll have to find a new roommate for Spring.

If I go with Roommate #2, I'll have a roommate for Fall/Winter/Spring, but I'll have to find a new roommate for Summer. If Roommate #2 could move in with me for the summer immediately, I would have picked him immediately.

Thanks in advanced!