Real fast keeper question, draft in 35 minutes please help

[Ken_AA]

I can keep 4 players...

firth 3 are easy Arod, Big Papi, Peavy

next one isnt easy.

Pettitte
Matt Holliday (OF Colorado)
Posada
Clint Barnes (SS Colorado)

standard 12 team 5x5 league. You can keep players forever so age could be a tie breaker.

Ken

[Ken_AA]

oppps... also Prior could be a keeper.

Ken

[rwperu34]

Pettitte.

[Ken_AA]

[ QUOTE ]
I can keep 4 players...

firth 3 are easy Arod, Big Papi, Peavy

next one isnt easy.

Pettitte
Matt Holliday (OF Colorado)
Posada
Clint Barnes (SS Colorado)

standard 12 team 5x5 league. You can keep players forever so age could be a tie breaker.
or prior

Ken

[/ QUOTE ]

I just traded ortiz to a big red sox fan for Vlad if that changes anything.

Ken

[Soul Daddy]

Post your whole team. I have a hard time believing these are your best possible options in a 12 team league.

[Ken_AA]

[ QUOTE ]
Post your whole team. I have a hard time believing these are your best possible options in a 12 team league.

[/ QUOTE ]

My team wasn;t great last year:

> C - J Posada (C)
> 1B - D Ortiz (1B, DH)
> 2B - F Lopez (2B,3B,SS)
> 3B - A Rodriguez (3B)
> SS - E Renteria (SS)
> OF - C Monroe (OF)
> OF - G Jenkins (OF)
> OF - G Anderson (OF)
> Util - T Clark (1B)
> BN - M Holliday (OF)
> BN - N Johnson (1B)
> BN - C Counsell (2B,SS)
> BN - R Sanders (OF)
> DL - C Barmes (SS)

> SP - J Peavy (SP)
> SP - A Pettitte (SP)
> RP - M Batista (RP,SP)
> RP - R Dempster (RP,SP)
> P - M Prior (SP)
> P - A Harang (SP)
> P - D Lowe (SP)
> BN - D Williams (SP)

I just traded Ortiz for Vlad also.

Ken

[Soul Daddy]

It's hard to see Pettitte matching last year's numbers, but he's safe, solid option. If you're risk averse, that's probably the pick. Holliday's okay, I guess. Prior scares the hell out of me, I don't think you can keep him as one of 4. Given that you don't have any sure things left, I think I take a shot with Lopez.

[Borgland]

Keep Harang. He's young and still developing. Going to be a Cy Young contender soon.

[wisehandpoker]

I like Felipe Lopez.

[eggzz]

[ QUOTE ]
I like Felipe Lopez.

[/ QUOTE ]