Have I Discovered Another Mathematical Football Coaching Error?

[MyTurn2Raise]

that isn't dumb, but one should really check the validity of there assumptions if they are going to go up against conventional wisdom

to present the argument as I've seen it presented is laughable

The first question should be 'what is wrong with the model?'
Instead, the proponent just questioned 'what is wrong with NFL coaches?'

that was dumb when the model is severely flawed

It's also silly in that I've heard that criticism before and there were posted sources that talked about it



Perhaps one should analyze whether it's better to go for 2 up 7 or kick the point.