12BB in SB vs CO open shove ~5BB

[hagbard celine]

I thought this was a clear reshove to isolate against the CO who should be open shoving really wide with 5BB when folded to him. However my roommate feels I could "wait for a better spot."

Thoughts?

Oh, my reads on Villain are that he has 5BB and should be shoving REALLY wide when folded to him in LP.

Full Tilt Poker
No Limit Holdem Tournament
Blinds: t500/t1000
(Ante: t125)
9 players
Converter

Seat 1: MarsMan2001 (12,676)
Seat 2: aniloj (31,168)
Seat 3: bubbster1963 (25,098)
Seat 4: andymp1 (17,030)
Seat 5: gonzorocks (19,195)
Seat 6: Nacho_177 (6,846)
Seat 7: dang69 (5,625)
Seat 8: CountDeMonet (18,144)
Seat 9: Hero (12,263)

MarsMan2001 antes 125
aniloj antes 125
bubbster1963 antes 125
andymp1 antes 125
gonzorocks antes 125
Nacho_177 antes 125
dang69 antes 125
CountDeMonet antes 125
Hero antes 125
Hero posts the small blind of 500
MarsMan2001 posts the big blind of 1,000
The button is in seat #8


Pre-flop: (9 players) Hero is SB with A[img]/images/graemlins/diamond.gif[/img] 5[img]/images/graemlins/diamond.gif[/img]
5 folds, <font color="#cc0000">CO raises all-in t5500</font>, Button folds, <font color="#cc0000">Hero?

[chrismystero]

Unless CO has been read as insanely nitty this is a pretty Standard reshove, especially considering you're pretty short yourself.

[WJL]

[ QUOTE ]
I thought this was a clear reshove to isolate against the CO who should be open shoving really wide with 5BB when folded to him. However my roommate feels I could "wait for a better spot."


[/ QUOTE ]

Your roommate is going to blind out. Shove.

[hagbard celine]

obv I shoved, and obv I lost to JTo or I never would have gotten into an argument with my roommate over whether or not that was a good spot, resulting in him saying, "I think you can fold there."

To which I respond, "That's an easy reshove, I'm way ahead of his range."

To which he says, "I think you're wrong."

After which I say, "You're an idiot,"

To which he says, "Post the hand, I bet people will say to fold."

Thereby resulting in me posting the hand, and wasting everybody's time.

Thanks