***Official Bicker about Manning vs. Brady Thread***

[PLO8FaceKilla]

Brady is proving this year how he is leagues ahead of Manning.

He's been playing with used car salesmen at receiver for years and still managed to win 3 superbowls with these mediocre weapons.

Manning had the best receiving group in the league for years and only managed 1 superbowl.

Now when Brady finally has weapons comparable to Manning's (with an inferior running back), he is blowing him out of the water in terms of stats and wins.

Manning's team suffers some injuries and all of a sudden we see how average he is with only decent receivers.

The patriots superbowl teams were littered with injuries on offense and defense and they never used excuses like this 2007 colts team.

The debate is officially over.

[mbillie1]

I'm pretty sure Eli Manning > Peyton > Brady > Vinnie Testaverde > Rex Grossman > the rest of the NFL

[splashpot]

[ QUOTE ]
The debate is officially over.

[/ QUOTE ]
Good. That means you will never post on the subject ever again, right? Please tell me I'm right.

[capone0]

[ QUOTE ]
Brady is proving this year how he is leagues ahead of Manning.

He's been playing with used car salesmen at receiver for years and still managed to win 3 superbowls with these mediocre weapons.

Manning had the best receiving group in the league for years and only managed 1 superbowl.

Now when Brady finally has weapons comparable to Manning's (with an inferior running back), he is blowing him out of the water in terms of stats and wins.

Manning's team suffers some injuries and all of a sudden we see how average he is with only decent receivers.

The patriots superbowl teams were littered with injuries on offense and defense and they never used excuses like this 2007 colts team.

The debate is officially over.

[/ QUOTE ]

Hmmmm.....

Brady's D >>>>>>>>>> Manning's D most of the time they've competed for a title. Brady never had to be as good as Manning had to be. Manning's D might be better than Brady's D this year but Brady's Pass O >>>>>>>>>>>>&g t;>>>>>>> Manning's this year.

[kyro]

God I hate PLO8killa so much. There is no excuse for him to still be posting.

[vixticator]

[ QUOTE ]
Manning and Brady are two of the greatest QBs ever to step on a football field, and we, as football fans, should feel blessed to have an opportunity to watch them week in and week out.

There, thread over.

[/ QUOTE ]

[PLO8FaceKilla]

[ QUOTE ]
God I hate PLO8killa so much. There is no excuse for him to still be posting.

[/ QUOTE ]

why don't you try addressing what i posted.

saying "troll" or saying you hate me only proves my point further.

If it's so ridiculous it should be very easy to provide a solid response.

[TMTTR]

How much do we discount Brady's rating for his coaches illegally recording the opposition's defense? [img]/images/graemlins/wink.gif[/img]

How much do we discount for the other as-of-yet-undiscovered ways that the Pats' coaches have been cheating since Belichick took over? [img]/images/graemlins/smirk.gif[/img]


Warning: This post is intended to rile up Patriot fans and should not be used to inspire serious debate.

[Kneel B4 Zod]

[ QUOTE ]
How much do we discount Brady's rating for his coaches illegally recording the opposition's defense?

[/ QUOTE ]

the videotaping clearly HURT Brady, ldo, just look at the #'s for this year vs last

[capone0]

So how will the rest of the teams in the NFL react. Let's say the Pats keep Moss. Will the rest of the teams try to grab up FAs from the Pats? Will the CBs have to get larger to overcome Moss? There will be a reaction to what the Pats have done by the NFL or the other teams. The 80s dynasties were fixed through FA. Now the Pats have gotten around it by getting good players to pay for less (Both Thomas and Moss are paid less than Market value, Thomas slightly less (9ers offered a bigger deal) and Moss much less (he took a paycut).

The Pats are fun, but they won't be fun for the NFL in the long run to lessen the parity that seemed to exist for the last 10 years.