Eli Manning/Rex Grossman

[iron81]

Because this can't be posted enough:

[HajiShirazu]

Problem is that grossman had a pretty good line last year as well as a good running game (granted he did only have average receivers), and was basically always winning so he didn't have to do much, and he still sucked ass.

[Jack Bando]

I've never seen that version Iron, I always see the blue tone one. TYVM.

I'd say Average Eli>Average Rex. But Good Rex (Come home soon!)>Good Eli

[Franchise 60]

[ QUOTE ]
Peyton threw 6 INTs a few games back. Therefore, I think he's terrible.

[/ QUOTE ]

Joey Harrington >>>> Peyton ldo

[MuresanForMVP]

Eli Manning looks like a complete loser retard 100% of the time. Has anyone else noticed just how idiotic he looks when he's about to get sacked and just underhands the ball into the ground? Its pretty much the most pathetic looking thing you could ever see in an NFL game. A youtube video of that would be gold.

[Golden_Rhino]

I guess the question will be answered when one of them wins the race to 3rd string.