LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring (GAME THREAD)

[aaronk56]

I will be voting Traz until he is dead in all future games for a long time. I said this to Sighing last night.

I protected Jeremy last night because Sighing said that Frodo couldn't be killed. Since everyone else in this game wants to turbolynch me other than Nich and Jeremy it was a logical choice.

I'm Aragorn, although I realize that there is nothing I can say to change any minds, but look at traz's record in this game, he was convinced that TFG wasn't evil, and he was sure, more so than with me, that thebram was evil. Go ahead and lynch me today if you want Nich killed tonight.

I won't be very active today but will try to check in on occasion.

[Nicholasp27]

now that we have all agreed that the wolves are sam hunting right now, what do we know?

a) this is why they didn't target me/aaron, so put me/aaron aside for now and find the wolves today

b) eating traz gives them a GREAT shot at sam (as i coulda cleared my masonry brother), sets up bram and aaron (the doctor), and gets rid of influential wolf-finder...it's first night they could go after traz since doc would no longer be protecting him and it gives them the above benefits

conclusion: we can NOT assume that eating traz was due to him being right about aaron...after all, he was wrong on bram so they prolly already figured he was likely not gandalf...but it was for the above benefits...thus we shouldn't treat aaron like a seer-confirmed baddie

[dmk]

[ QUOTE ]
Nich

Please explain why, in a game with a role-blocker, you role revealed your single peek, when that peek was the seer?

[/ QUOTE ]

nich, you never answered this

[Nicholasp27]

i revealed him as vanillager because he had some heat and i had some heat...figured i'd come out and clear both of the seers, get doc protection and hopefully they'd buy that he was villager

i didn't see that there was a roleblocker, and i apologized for this

[Neil S]

I for one think they're probably Aragorn hunting, since I now wonder if they just lucked into Gandalf.

[Nicholasp27]

why would they aragorn hunt?

the ENTIRE key to them giving the village ZERO more peeks is to kill sam

PERIOD

[Neil S]

Unless Aaron is Saruman, that is.

[Neil S]

Er, no, sorry. It's the Witch-King that's the roleblocker; just checked that. Got confused a moment because it's Saruman in the books that blocks Gandalf, heh.

[Jeremy517]

This might be my last post in the thread. My wife is being induced into labor today. I definitely won't be back today, and unless there is an internet connection at the hospital, I'll have to be subbed tomorrow.

Please think about your vote today. If you think there is a chance that Aaron is Aragorn, don't vote for him. There is plenty of time to vote for him closer to must-lynch.

[soah]

traz said bram before aaron. there's no way then that he had peeked aaron as evil unless he had also peeked bram as evil which he obviously had not. so there is no reason to lynch aaron today.

vote jeremy