IGN Top 100

[jah7_fsu1]

[ QUOTE ]
On a completely different note, am I the only one who thinks Wind Waker is underrated?

[/ QUOTE ]

I think WW is a phenomenal game and constantly an underrated Zelda game. I also think Zelda 2 (Link's Awakening) is one of the best games ever so maybe I just like the games "normal" Zelda fans think are the weaker ones. I wouldn't put WW above Twilight Princess or Ocarina...but I would rank it right about even with Majora's Mask. So you aren't alone [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[GBP04]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
On a completely different note, am I the only one who thinks Wind Waker is underrated?

[/ QUOTE ]

I think WW is a phenomenal game and constantly an underrated Zelda game. I also think Zelda 2 (Link's Awakening) is one of the best games ever so maybe I just like the games "normal" Zelda fans think are the weaker ones. I wouldn't put WW above Twilight Princess or Ocarina...but I would rank it right about even with Majora's Mask. So you aren't alone [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

[/ QUOTE ]

I'd go 1. Ocarina of Time 2. Link to the Past 3. Wind Waker 4. Majora's Mask 5. Twilight Princess 6. Phantom Hourglass


Twilight Princess was a great game, but the lack of people in the world (same with Phantom Hourglass) really annoyed me.

[Chilltown]

1. Ocarina 2. LTTP 3. Majora's Mask 4. Twilight Prince 5. Wind Waker for me. I really hated the fact that WW had too much sailing, too much tedious treasure hunting, too small of a land world. Still an amazing game, but weaker than the other in my book. Boss battles were jokes, never really a serious threat of death, but from the start of game till the master sword was near perfect.

[memento_mori]

Ugh, I really hoped that Pokemon Blue/Red would place better than 37, might be the greatest Gameboy game ever.

[sixfour]

[ QUOTE ]
Ugh, I really hoped that Pokemon Blue/Red would place better than 37, might be the greatest Gameboy game ever.

[/ QUOTE ]

Pokemon RBY is OK, but that statement is lol-worthy.

30-21 is a bit odd, by their criteria SFII should be nowhere near that low, and they're using up too many of their "cult PC games that were great but nobody bought" selections here. Also nobody's going to remember KotoR in three years' time, and Mario Kart basically was fine for a couple of years until Street Racer did everything better and MK64 surpassed it completely

[sixfour]

The Zelda series goes OoT, LA, ALttP, TP and LoZ for me. Tried MM but got bored of it after the great bay temple made me lose the will to live. Tried playing Zelda 2 but could never get into it. Borrowed Wind Waker off someone but never actually put it in the Cube as Ikaruga was taking up too much time

[Chris Daddy Cool]

there is a lot of talk about halo and the like surpassing goldeneye. fwiw, i don't even really like the halo series that much, but i will still play goldeneye from time to time.

also i would agree that there is a distinction between "great for its time" and just flat out "great right now"

games like OOT, goldeneye, smb64, smb3, and ff6 still fit that criteria of greatness for me.

of my childhood favorites, super mario kart has slipped imo and is actually probably suprassed by the gameboy advance mario kart.

haven't checked the list lately, but is civ4 up there? i could see that game still being great 15 years from now.

[goofyballer]

[ QUOTE ]
they're using up too many of their "cult PC games that were great but nobody bought" selections here

[/ QUOTE ]

Uh, what? X-Com: UFO Defense is the only one of those games I'm not familiar with and SS2 is the only other one that might be considered a "cult game nobody bought," and it's deservedly on that list because it's one of the best shooters ever (see Zero Punctuation's BioShock review for reference). Warcraft II, SimCity 2000, and Half-Life aren't cult games, nor did nobody buy them.

I'm glad they didn't ride Half-Life's nuts into the top 25, although I'm sure HL2 will be a little overrated.

[chuckleslovakian]

Shadow of the Colossus is a huge stretch at #16. I mean I love the game and all but it is between Castlevania: Symphony of the Night and Super Mario World. I know Shadow is pretty and all, but come on.

[MrWookie]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
they're using up too many of their "cult PC games that were great but nobody bought" selections here

[/ QUOTE ]

Uh, what? X-Com: UFO Defense is the only one of those games I'm not familiar with and SS2 is the only other one that might be considered a "cult game nobody bought," and it's deservedly on that list because it's one of the best shooters ever (see Zero Punctuation's BioShock review for reference). Warcraft II, SimCity 2000, and Half-Life aren't cult games, nor did nobody buy them.

I'm glad they didn't ride Half-Life's nuts into the top 25, although I'm sure HL2 will be a little overrated.

[/ QUOTE ]

Man, I think XCom and HL were placed much too low. I didn't like HL2 nearly as much as the original, so if HL2 is in the top 10, I'll be very sad. The guys at IGN's PC branch clearly didn't have much say in this list, since they crowned XCom the #1 PC game of all time, and deservedly so imo. Yet, they mention that the PC guys gave it the #1, and they stick it behind a bunch of other great, but not quite as perfect (imo) PC games.