Halloween WW - Costume Party (Game Thread)

[jgunnip]

[ QUOTE ]
Before we make it nightfall I'd also like to hear who jgnunnip is going to target for his pumpkin action

[/ QUOTE ]

suggestions?

[clowntable]

[ QUOTE ]
OH: How can you be a pro village role if you don't die at night and cannot be lynched?

[/ QUOTE ]

[wdcbooks]

Dan sent several PMs to me, saying "I am just going to say that you (Books) never contacted me, and if we are still alive tomorrow we can straighten it out". I sent a PM back saying that I would prefer he say that I have a power that is useful in the right spots and asking him to give his own assessment of whether I was telling the truth. I did that to make sure that Dan would go on the record with his own assessment of whether he believed me. I felt that with the information I gave him, he would have to believe for an almost certainty that I was a villager.

He did that, although briefly, but I questioned how it could possibly be helpful to say that he didn't contact me as we were exchanging nearly a dozen PMs. I once thought Dan was a certain villager and I am wavering hard because of that, and because of his lack of masoning with Nich, or any other potential seer candidate.

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
Item: Books and Dan can not both be good roles.

[/ QUOTE ]

If books is a good role, we both are.

[antidan444]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
AntiDan makes me a little uneasy. We exchanged numerous PMs yesterday and I explained my exact role in a way that I felt made it dead obvious that I was a villager. At one point he asked what I wanted to have said in thread and he pushed to say "I contacted Books and he never responded". I can't for the life of me understand why this would be a good idea. I also suggested that I was an odd choice for mason because I couldn't be the seer. So today not only does he not mason with Nich, he chooses Eskimo, another not-seer.

[/ QUOTE ]

Okay, this is what I was remembering. If this is true, though, I'm happy I dug it up, because this is distinctly odd behavior by antidan.

Antidan?

[/ QUOTE ]

If I was still masoning with books, I would explain to him the reasoning (possibly faulty) why I thought that might be a good idea. Since I'm not, and I'd have to explain it in the thread, I'd rather not explain it.

Looks bad, I admit. If you think it looks too bad, lynch me.

[antidan444]

Other than that, I'm not defending myself anymore. I've played a pretty terrible game, and I'm ready for a long break from WW, so if I get lynched, whatever. But I am a villager, and I think anyone who spends ... God, it'd probably take hours, sorry about that ... to reread me, they'd come to that conclusion, even despite my missteps.

[antidan444]

I'm willing to accept suggestions for tomorrow's masonry, BTW.

[VoraciousReader]

You keep saying "if it looks bad lynch me". If I had the votes, I would. I think it would be a pro-village thing to do.

[antidan444]

Can someone explain to me why everyone is considering VR a villager? If OH is a wolf isn't VR likely to be?

This isn't an accusation, I just am unclear about things.

[antidan444]

VR,

It definitely would not be pro-village, though given my craptastic role it wouldn't be the most anti-village play either.