POG All-Star Game #2 Game Thread!

[Nicholasp27]

i still like my list

when i get new info (lynch reveal and night kill), i'll re-read the thread and re-evaluate

[wdcbooks]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Any chance we can get a special rule to end Day 1 at 10pm tonight? I would like to start Demon-2 before Christmas.

[/ QUOTE ]

why don't we all just agree that when 10 pm comes, we'll all put our votes on whoever is in the lead?

[/ QUOTE ]

Pudley, I am with you on that pact, except I will be out playing poker tonight. I would proxy to you, trusting you to follow that strategy though.

[Zurvan]

No proxies, please.

[durron597]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I have no clue why WillMagic is close to the lead right now. Do people really think he is playing his wolf game right now? I notice Durron has his vote on him just because WM is in the lead. I mention this because Durron was the one who figured him out as wolf in Average VI.

[/ QUOTE ]

there were a few things that stood out to me about him that might be willmagic-wolf (I wouldn't vote someone I was sure was a villager)

[/ QUOTE ]
Do go on

[/ QUOTE ]

His total 180 flipflop on both BobO (villager -> wolf) and sighing (wolf -> villager) are signature Willmagic-wolf plays that I've seen him do in both Mish-Mash 2 and ASVI. All day yesterday he was sighing sighing sighing and now that it's apparent sighing is unlikely to be lynched suddenly he's "uncomfortable with the vote". In fact he is even suspecting BobO right now specifically for Bobo's vote on sighing... that post was very wolfy but usually I don't go WOLF WOLF WOLF ZOMG for someone voting for a person that is one of my main candidates.

Also, I would say 80% of his posting yesterday was about Sighing and most of his comments on other players was very substance free, specifically his stuff about VR and amplify.

Please note that he is not at the top of my list, I have better reasoning for other people but if I have to decide between Amp and Willmagic, Willmagic seems the clear choice here.

[Tokyo!!]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Does anyone who is NOT Shortline want to defend him?

[/ QUOTE ]
I'll take a stab at it...

-- If Shortline is a wolf, you won't know it.

-- If Shortline is acting wolfy, it's because he's a villager.

-- If you think Shortline is a wolf, you're probably wrong.

How's that?

[/ QUOTE ]

*blinks*

[Tokyo!!]

[ QUOTE ]
Tokyo, there is something you missed in your analysis of xorbie. One second and I'll dig it up.

[/ QUOTE ]

zomg im excited. but he only made like 3 posts?

[Jonsan]

countif?

[Our House]

[ QUOTE ]
Xorbie finally pops in, and who is his big suspect? VR. I dunno how the rest of you guys view VR, but I find her to be one of the most easily readable players for me anyway. This is like a jabillion percent her villager game. When someone pops in and accuses a clear villager in my mind, it sets of red flags. He then says that this is because VR said shorty is a wolf. Well he is duh, so thats good lookin out by VR. Then he says amp isnt a wolf, who is one.

[/ QUOTE ]
Keep in mind that I'm not sticking up for xorbie when I say this because he may very well be a wolf, but:

I read VR incredibly well in turbos. If there's a difference in long games, please fill me in. Her first day posts were bad (no offense intended VR). Xorbie echoed my thoughts in that post at the time. Her posts were much better today. Yesterday was probably just a bad posting day for her. Xorbie made his statement before today's posts.

Note the bold and italicized part of your quote.

Now, PLEASE tell me how VR was such a CLEAR VILLAGER to you at the time of xorbie's post! Please tell me this. You claim to read her well. HOW ON EARTH DID YOU SEE CLEAR VILLAGER IN HER AT THAT TIME??

Remember, I'm not saying xorbie isn't a wolf, but your timing is off somewhere and your post accusing him is unfounded. If xorbie made that post today, I'd understand....but he didn't.

[Zurvan]

[ 5 ] amplify votes WillMagic
[ 2 ] BobOjedaFan votes sighing
[ 0 ] Chuckleslovakian votes amplify
[ 1 ] durron597 votes WillMagic
[ 2 ] fnord_too votes sighing
[ 0 ] GetThere1Time votes fnord_too
[ 0 ] Jonsan votes amplify
[ 0 ] kyro votes amplify
[ 0 ] KyrosMother votes WillMagic
[ 0 ] Nicholasp27 votes Shortline99
[ 0 ] Our House votes durron597
[ 0 ] pudley4 votes WillMagic
[ 1 ] Shortline99 votes WillMagic
[ 3 ] sighing votes WillMagic
[ 0 ] Thebram votes WillMagic
[ 0 ] Tokyo!! votes amplify
[ 0 ] traz votes BobOjedaFan
[ 0 ] VoraciousReader votes fnord_too
[ 0 ] wdcbooks votes amplify
<font color="red"> [ 6 ] WillMagic votes BobOjedaFan </font>
[ 0 ] xorbie votes sighing

[shortline99]

something is wrong with that countif.